Frederik Ramm wrote: > Hi, > > >> Also the other problem with >> splitting and merging of roads needs attention. Rather urgently I would >> say. >> > > I agree. It is however again one of the problems where different > relations will need different actions - when a way in a route relation > is split, both new ways need to be members, but when a way in a turn > restriction relation is split, only the one at the junction should be > a member. > > Somehow I always thought that we should have a rather complex > "presets" style configuration file for JOSM that tells it what to do > with various kinds of relations but maybe a simple hack would be > better than nothing for now; in the case of splitting ways perhaps > just always ask the user what he wants. > > Bye > Frederik > That sounds wonderful to me. Maybe a bit harder for people who are just starting, but they'll overcome it quickly enough. It's certainly better than breaking route relations. What if somebody tries to do the opposite (re)combine a road, where part of it is part of a route relation? This should simply be impossible. In fact I'm a bit disappointed the API doesn't simply forbid this, but that probably also has to do with the different kind of possible relations. I must admit that I didn't look into turn restriction and house numbering relations and what would be the requirements to implement those yet.
Polyglot _______________________________________________ talk mailing list [email protected] http://lists.openstreetmap.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/talk

