Yeah, groundspeak have been very obtuse regarding 'commercialness' of caches in the uk recently. It's left the uk caching community with a very sour taste in their mouths. OSM is exactly the opposite of commercial - is it not registered as a non-profit charity? (Ah, but GS also have a dislike for charities, so we're just a non-profit group...)
On 27/11/2008, Till Harbaum / Lists <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Hi, > > it's restored. They say that they thought OSM was an unreliable commercial > (due to > the request for donations) service which they don't want to have their users > to do. > > Kind of strange explanation as the purpose of OSM is pretty obvious and my > cache > even said "osm is for streetmaps what wikipedia is for encyclopedia". So the > idea > that it's non-commercial basically can't be missed. > > Till > > > Am Mittwoch 26 November 2008 schrieb Nick Black: >> Did you get anywhere with this? Have you tried emailing the admins at >> geocaching.com to see why they removed the cache? I'd love to hear more. >> >> Nick >> >> >> On Sat, Nov 15, 2008 at 2:02 PM, Thomas Wood >> <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>wrote: >> >> > 2008/11/15 Till Harbaum / Lists <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>: >> > > Hi, >> > > >> > > i have recently released a geocache which basically required you to >> > > look >> > up a certain node >> > > in the OSM database. The position of that node was then the place >> > > where >> > the geocache was >> > > hidden. Geocaching.com users can perhaps still read the original >> > > listing >> > at: >> > > >> > http://www.geocaching.com/seek/cache_details.aspx?guid=80a9308b-6719-485d-a0dc-846798a8cac2 >> > >> > Through a bug in their site code, the original listing is visible >> > here: >> > http://www.geocaching.com/seek/cdpf.aspx?guid=80a9308b-6719-485d-a0dc-846798a8cac2 >> > >> > > Geocaching.com recently completely deleted that cache antry as they >> > > claim >> > that it forces you to use a certain >> > > software (a web browser!!!) and a certain web service. >> > >> > They have un-published the listing, an event that occurs not very >> > often - usually only if the reviewer who published it realises they >> > made a mistake soon after. >> > The specific guideline reads something like caches that require >> > (unusual) third party software to be installed are not permitted, >> > there's also a similar rule about cache perminance in terms of >> > external resources on the net - eg hosting an mp3 on a personal >> > website will not be acceptable as a part of the 'puzzle' as they have >> > a habit of falling offline. >> > >> > > This is a strange explanation as geocaches requesting you to find a >> > certain image on google earth >> > > are pretty common. On the other hand Geocaching.com seems to have a >> > business with google. This >> > > may be the explanation why they don't like to deal with openstreetmap. >> > > I >> > really wonder if >> > > it's google behind this. >> > >> > They have business with Google as far as using their Maps API, >> > publishing KML files, and using AdWords, I don't think they have any >> > further links with them. >> > >> > > This includes quite extreme behaviour on the GC.com side as they are >> > > not >> > using their usual methods >> > > of disabling or archiving caches. Instead they reset their entire >> > database with respect to this >> > > cache to the state before it was published. It's like they really want >> > > to >> > clean all traces related to >> > > this geocache. >> > >> > "The GC.com" side is usually just a volunteer reviewer rather than one >> > of the company's employees. As noted, caches can be removed completely >> > from the site - 'unpublished' on the event of the reviewer making a >> > mistake. >> > >> > > IMHO a very interesting issue and may mean that google sees a serious >> > competitor arriving ... >> > >> > Not in my view. >> > >> > > Till >> > >> > I'm asking some contacts I have to see if I can get the full logs for >> > publishing and subsequent removal of it to see if a reason is further >> > given. >> > >> > -- >> > Regards, >> > Thomas Wood >> > (Edgemaster) >> > >> > _______________________________________________ >> > talk mailing list >> > [email protected] >> > http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk >> > >> >> >> > > > -- Regards, Thomas Wood (Edgemaster) _______________________________________________ talk mailing list [email protected] http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk

