2009/9/2 Martin Koppenhoefer <[email protected]>: > 2009/9/2 Peter Miller <[email protected]>: >> I spoke to members of the Data Working Group recently and it seems clear to >> me (and them) that dealing with vandalism is in general a community problem, >> not their problem. They are mainly about dealing with those situations where >> a legal response is required such as copyright violation or where an >> official email might help. > > this sounds reasonable > >> Banning people is a possible last-resort, > > +1. Even if it might not be very powerful (just create another account > and here you are again) > >> but >> this does not deal with removing graffiti or spotting it in the first place >> which should be done by the community. > > +1 > >> I believe that monitoring of graffiti (which this is) > > no, IMHO that's no more graffiti but it's removing the covers of > manholes, maybe even poisoning the drinking water reserve ;-). It is > too big to remove manually. If like throwing a lot of > paint-cluster-bombs over wide areas. Think of 880 ways in Ireland: > that's too much to ask the community to do it manually. Reverts at > that scale (if they are really 100% useless or harmful) should be > dealt with in a more professional way than hitting 880 times "h" in > potlatch. > > Not everybody is able to run revert.pl like Richard suggested, that's > why some members of the community started this thread: to ask the more > experienced/enabled community members for help in doing so. > > cheers, > Martin
The thread was started for consensus on whether the edits were vandalism, and what should be done. Now we're at a stage that we've confirmed it is 100% harmful, we can get them reverted. -- Regards, Thomas Wood (Edgemaster) _______________________________________________ talk mailing list [email protected] http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk

