2012/11/30 Rob Nickerson <[email protected]>: > I was aware of key:entrance but building:part was new to me so thanks for > letting me know about that one. In regards to the following, can you please > explain a little more about _how_ to map these. For example, I understand 1a > but what nodes/ways/closed ways are you suggesting tagging in 1b and 2a? > 1a) a node for the shop floating inside the building > 1b) like 1a but part of the outline > 2a) a multipolygon with the building as outer > 2b) an explicit polygon overlapping with the building
actually I wouldn't suggest 1b (see above) because I'd consider it slightly wrong from a topologic point of view. I would use 1a or 2a in the case that the outline of the POI is the same as the building outline. In 2a) you make a relation, type multipolygon, and add tags for the poi to this (name, amenity, etc.), then you add the way that delimits the POI (i.e. a closed way, the building polygon) with the role "outer" to the relation. > Sounds like a building with 2 shops would best be mapped as 3 closed ways - > 1 for the building, and 2 inside the building that give the position of the > shop and are tagged with amenity=*, name=*, addr (and optionaly > building:part=yes). These 2 inner closed ways are likely to share boundaries > with the builiding closed way and with each other. Would you tend to agree? yes, for 2 shops on the same floor, otherwise we should add the floor level to the POI-objects. Most people according to current mapping practise would rather add 2 floating nodes somewhere inside the building polygon I think. cheers, Martin _______________________________________________ talk mailing list [email protected] http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk

