…..Actually, all the overlapping ways in the current shapefile are where 
adjacent relations meet.

> On 19 Feb 2017, at 2:04 PM, nwastra <[email protected]> wrote:
> 
> Hi
> is there a JOSM plugin to assist with duplicate ways?
> 
> We have been given explicit permission to use a good data set of shapefiles 
> that define boundaries for the OSM.
> 
> Using JOSM, my method is to select the shapefile relation for a particular 
> National Park for instance then merge the selection into the OSM Data Layer. 
> Often a replace geometry is needed on many polygons to help preserve the 
> history. Add all the tags to the relation. 
> 
> Then the hard part….
> You have to cut up and conflate the new boundaries with the existing data. 
> All the duplicate overlying ways need to be selected, nodes entered, nodes 
> merged and joined at the end, boundary and nodes selected where split is 
> performed, remove extra over lapping ways to generally leave one, add that 
> one left to this or another relation. Add more tags as needed.
> Then selection each relation that was affected and view the result to see if 
> it is complete.
> 
> In some areas there are likely to be National Parks and other protected 
> areas, forestry areas, etc all adjacent to each other with boundaries that 
> meet.
> 
> Another method I use is to split up the relation before merging piece by 
> piece but is just as complex.
> 
> Another method is to leave the overlapping ways for someone else to sort out.
> 
> In some relations there may be 30 or so adjacent polygons with ways partially 
> overlapping so is a lot of work that I think would be ideal for plugin 
> assistance and efficiency. 
> It seems to me that if one relation is selected at a time, it should be a 
> task able to be mostly automated by programming. Then it would be up to the 
> mapper to verify and quality control the result.
> 
> I am a new user to QGis and wonder if the splitting and conflating of the 
> shapefile to be merged can be done in QGis prior to introduction to JOSM and 
> then would only need to sort out areas between adjacent relations. 
> 
> Is it best not to bother doing this anyway or even preferable to leave all 
> the polygons as individual entities with overlapping ways?
> 
> Finally, I should add that I do try to add small discreet areas and relations 
> one at a time that are manageable before proceeding. 
> 
> Nev     
> 


_______________________________________________
talk mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk

Reply via email to