I think a lot of these questions cannot be answered in a boolean fashion.
Take the first one "Provide Designer/developer separation?". Both JSF and
Tapestry provide separation, but IMO JSF alienates the Creative UI designer
that is used to working only with Dreamweaver whereas Tapestry has much less
intrusion into the .html code.
I think something like this would be excellent to gather information on, but
I think you need to lead us with the questions a little better. For
instance
Provide Designer/developer separation?
Code Snippets
UI Designer learning curve
Configuration required (i.e. .page, faces-config.xml, etc)
Toolsets (i.e. Spindle, MyEclipseIDE, DreamWeaver, WSAD, etc)
A yes/no survey leaves to much room for somebody wanting to market their
framework and can lead to a decision based on very little exposure. There
seems to be a lot of different frame works coming out in the past three
years and a review like this would be priceless in making solid decisions.
Another interesting statistic would be to see how many people have dropped
one framework for another. I for one have come from the JSF (MyFaces) camp
and am hoping Tapestry is going to make my life easier in many areas.
Good luck!
Aaron Bartell
http://mowyourlawn.com/blog
-----Original Message-----
From: news [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Sohaib Akhtar
Sent: Friday, January 27, 2006 6:36 AM
To: [email protected]
Subject: Need Help in Evaluation of Framework
I need someone's help. I am doing research study on open source frameworks.
One of its requirements is that I should provide comparison analysis that
which framework support which feature (These are the feature, which could be
used for selection of framework). As I have not worked on Tapestry so I need
any of you to fill in the following table. You only have to respond in
Yes/No.
Yes, means Tapestry have this feature and No means it doesn't.
Thanks in Advance for your support.
Feature
Provide Designer/developer separation?
Can be Coupled easily with Organization Code?
Built-in Internationalization (I18N) Support?
Provide built-in Security framework?
Provide Validation and conversion support?
Can Manage Component State?
Support new Component's development?
Provide built-in Standard components?
Provide User documentation?
Provide Error handling support?
Built-in Testability?
Increase Developer productivity?
Have IDE/tool support?
Is easy to learn?
Is Extensible?
Free Licensing?
Which programming language is supported?
Support Integration with other technologies?
If anyone of you is willing and having problem in understanding, please let
me know your email, i can provide the definition of each feature.
Thanks again.
Sohaib
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
