Fri, Feb 19, 2010 at 05:54:30PM +0000, Iain Hibbert: > On Fri, 19 Feb 2010, john heasley wrote: > > > poll(2) reads: > > > > POLLHUP The device or socket has been disconnected. This flag > > is > > always checked, even if not present in the events > > bitmask. > > Note that POLLHUP and POLLOUT should never be present in > > the revents bitmask at the same time. If the remote end > > of a socket is closed, poll() returns a POLLIN event, > > rather than a POLLHUP. > > > > I believe, and the pipe_poll() seems to confirm, that POLLIN and POLLHUP > > are NOT mutually exclusive in the case of the read side of a pipe reaching > > EOF. That both, and POLLRDNORM if requested, are set. Which is correct? > > I'm not sure what you are asking. The above paragraph doesn't mention > POLLIN wrt pipes. It does say that when a *socket* is closed from the > remote end, you will get a POLLIN rather than POLLHUP. > > pipe != socket && in != out ?
good point; i didn't think of the two (nor device) differently. but, why should they be different? SuSv3 doesn't mention socket either. Its just a file descriptor though; shouldn't it be consistent?
