David Holland <[email protected]> wrote: > On Tue, Oct 23, 2012 at 07:53:28PM +0200, Edgar Fu? wrote: > > > the output of ps -lax on the NFS server during the 18-20 second > > > window > > > > As far as I remember (you need the s option, too), the main nfsd > > thread is on select, one subthread on biowait or biolock and the > > others on tstile. > > It would really be nice to know what those others are waiting behind. > > paging rmind... > > > Explanation to those following along at home: rmind has been claiming > for years that there is no need to have real wchan names instead of > "tstile", which just means "I'm waiting for something". He claims it's > easy to diagnose problems without that information. So when one comes > up it's time for him to prove it. :-) >
"Easy to diagnose problems"? Plain false. The lock naming you are talking about would give no *more* information than "it is a vnode lock", and one can guess already that it is most likely the case here (what a surprise!). To diagnose the problem, one needs quite more information than your useless lock naming would provide: for example, in almost any case, backtraces of the LWPs are required to figure out what is going on. Unless the case is very obvious/simplistic, lock naming will not explain the deadlock without the backtraces. I have said this multiple times. If you are unable to see the difference between the statements, then I cannot help you. Nor I am interested in discussion with somebody who does not bother to listen. -- Mindaugas
