CHURCHILL

“*Never Give In*” “This is the lesson: never give in, never give in, never,
never, never, never—in nothing, great or small, large or petty—never give
in except to convictions of honour and good sense. Never yield to force;
never yield to the apparently overwhelming might of the enemy.” (Dogmatic
words of Churchill).

2     *BBC's world affairs editor examines how an all-too-human politician
became a great wartime prime minister.*

*The 10 greatest controversies of Winston Churchill's career (22 January
2015)* <http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-29701767>

During Britain's darkest hours in World War Two, Churchill's leadership was
vital in maintaining morale and leading the country to eventual victory
over Nazi Germany.

In 2002 Churchill *saw off*
<http://www.bbc.co.uk/pressoffice/pressreleases/stories/2002/08_august/21/100_list.shtml>
the
likes of Shakespeare, Darwin and Brunel to be voted the greatest ever
Briton.

But in a career spanning some 70 years, he had more than a few moments of
controversy.

"There's a danger in Churchill gaining a purely iconic status because that
actually takes away from his humanity," says Allen Packwood, director of
the Churchill Archives Centre.

"He is this incredibly complex, contradictory and larger-than-life human
being and he wrestled with these contradictions during his lifetime."

Here are 10 of the most common debates that have raged about Churchill's
legacy.

*1. Views on race*

In April last year, Labour candidate Benjamin Whittingham tweeted that
Churchill was "a racist and white supremacist".

Sir Nicholas Soames, Churchill's grandson, was outraged. And Whittingham's
Conservative opponent Ben Wallace labelled the comments "ignorant" and
"incredibly insulting". The tweet was deleted and the Labour Party said:
"[It] does not represent the view of the Labour Party. He apologises
unreservedly if it has caused any offence."

But there have previously been suggestions that Churchill held racist
beliefs.

In 1937, *he told the Palestine Royal Commission*
<http://books.google.co.uk/books?id=ihWyeQchBScC&pg=PA9&lpg=PA9&dq=palestine+royal+commission+report+churchill+red+indians&source=bl&ots=fqe10nKhWa&sig=GcbUowychoxzbRVPV9CYbqkB1T8&hl=en&sa=X&ei=quhAVFji1e4G_ceAsAU&ved=0CFEQ6AEwBw#v=onepage&q=palestine%20royal%20commission%20report%20churchill%20red%20indians&f=false>:
"I do not admit for instance, that a great wrong has been done to the Red
Indians of America or the black people of Australia. I do not admit that a
wrong has been done to these people by the fact that a stronger race, a
higher-grade race, a more worldly-wise race to put it that way, has come in
and taken their place." { ABSOLUTE RACIST than Hitler }KR

Churchill certainly believed in racial hierarchies and eugenics, says John
Charmley, author of Churchill: The End of Glory. In Churchill's view, white
protestant Christians were at the top, above white Catholics, while Indians
were higher than Africans, he adds. "Churchill saw himself and Britain as
being the winners in a social Darwinian hierarchy."

*2. Poison gas*

Churchill has been criticised for advocating the use of chemical weapons -
primarily against Kurds and Afghans.

"I cannot understand this squeamishness about the use of gas," *he wrote in
a memo*
<https://www.nationalchurchillmuseum.org/churchills-1919-war-office-memorandum.html#:~:text=War%20Office%20Memo-,Churchill's%201919%20War%20Office%20Memorandum,about%20the%20use%20of%20gas.&text=It%20is%20not%20necessary%20to,on%20most%20of%20those%20affected>
during
his role as minister for war and air in 1919.

"I am strongly in favour of using poisoned gas against uncivilised tribes,"
he continued.{KR  HITLER DID THE SAME ON NAZI}

These quotes have been used by critics such as Noam Chomsky to attack
Churchill.

But the controversy is misplaced, says Warren Dockter, a research fellow at
the University of Cambridge and the author of Winston Churchill and the
Islamic World. "What he was proposing to use in Mesopotamia was
lachrymatory gas, which is essentially tear gas, not mustard gas."

Churchill's 1919 memo continued: "The moral effect should be so good that
the loss of life should be reduced to a minimum. It is not necessary to use
only the most deadly gasses: gasses can be used which cause great
inconvenience and would spread a lively terror and yet would leave no
serious permanent effect on most of those affected."

But some still criticise *the British air attacks*
<http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-29441383> used to quell rebellious
tribes in the region.

*3. Bengal famine*

In 1943, India, then still a British possession, experienced a disastrous
famine in the north-eastern region of Bengal - sparked by the Japanese
occupation of Burma the year before.

At least three million people are believed to have died - and Churchill's
actions, or lack thereof, have been the subject of criticism.

Madhusree Mukerjee, author of Churchill's Secret War, has said that despite
refusing to meet India's need for wheat, *he continued to insist that it
exported rice*
<http://harpers.org/blog/2010/11/churchills-dark-side-six-questions-for-madhusree-mukerjee/>
to
fuel the war effort.

"[The War Cabinet] ordered the build-up of a stockpile of wheat for feeding
European civilians after they had been liberated. So 170,000 tons of
Australian wheat bypassed starving India - destined not for consumption but
for storage," she said upon release of the book in 2010.

Churchill even *appeared to blame the Indians for the famine*
<http://www.winstonchurchill.org/learn/in-the-media/churchill-in-the-news/966-without-churchill-indias-famine-would-have-been-worse>,
claiming they "breed like rabbits".

"It's one of the worst blots on his record," says Toye. "It clearly is the
case that it was difficult for people to get him to take the issue
seriously."

"Churchill viewed it as a distraction," he explains. Preoccupied with
battling Germany in Europe, Churchill didn't want to be bothered by it when
people raised the issue.

It was a horrendous event but it needs to be seen within the context of
global war, says Packwood.

"Churchill is running a global war at this point and there are always going
to be conflicting priorities and demands," he says. "It's an incredibly
complex and evolving situation - and he's not always going to get
everything right."

Churchill on Gandhi: "A seditious lawyer, posing as a fakir"

*4. Statements about Gandhi*

Churchill had strong views on the man now widely respected for his work in
advocating self-determination for India.

"It is alarming and nauseating to see Mr Gandhi, a seditious Middle Temple
lawyer, now posing as a fakir… striding half-naked up the steps of the
Vice-regal Palace," Churchill said of his anti-colonialist adversary in
1931.

"Gandhi should not be released on the account of a mere threat of fasting,"
Churchill told the cabinet on another occasion. "We should be rid of a bad
man and an enemy of the Empire if he died."

He was vociferous in his opposition to Gandhi, says Toye, and didn't want
India to make any moves towards self-government to the extent of opposing
his own party's leaders and being generally quite hostile to Hinduism.

"[Churchill] was terribly alarmed that giving the Indians home rule was
going to lead to the downfall of the British Empire and the end of
civilisation."{KR FUNNY FELLOW}.

*5. Attitudes towards Jews*

In 2012 there were objections to a proposed Churchill Centre in Jerusalem
on the basis that he was "no stranger to the latent anti-Semitism of his
generation and class".

Sir Martin Gilbert, Churchill's official biographer, *countered that*
<http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/middleeast/israel/9005496/Plans-for-Winston-Churchill-centre-in-Israel-spark-controversy.html>
"he
was familiar with the Zionist ideal and supported the idea of a Jewish
state".

"Churchill with no doubt at all was a fervent Zionist," he says, "a fervent
believer in the right of the Jewish people to a state of their own and that
state should be in what we then called Palestine."

But he also "shared the low-level casual anti-Semitism of his class and
kind", he says. If we judged everyone of that era by the standards of 21st
Century political correctness, they'd all be guilty, he notes. "It
shouldn't blind us to the bigger picture."

A 1937 unpublished article - supposedly by Churchill - entitled "How the
Jews Can Combat Persecution" was discovered in 2007. "It may be that,
unwittingly, they are inviting persecution - that they have been partly
responsible for the antagonism from which they suffer," it said. "There is the
feeling that the Jew is an incorrigible alien, that his first loyalty will
always be towards his own race."

*6. Attitudes towards Islam*

Weston was quoting from Churchill's 1899 book The River War, in which he
wrote: "How dreadful are the curses which Mohammedanism lays on its
votaries! Besides the fanatical frenzy, which is as dangerous in a man as
hydrophobia [rabies] in a dog, there is this fearful fatalistic apathy.

"Improvident habits, slovenly systems of agriculture, sluggish methods of
commerce and insecurity of property exist wherever the followers of the
Prophet rule or live."

Snippets of these quotes now accompany Churchill's face in numerous
internet memes purporting to show his anti-Islam stance.

*7. Treatment of strikers*

Churchill's reputation as being anti-union primarily stems from an incident
in 1910.

His handling of the Tonypandy Riots that year was the source of much
controversy and invited ill-feeling towards him in south Wales for the rest
of his life.

His grandson *even had to defend Churchill's actions*
<http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/obituaries/politics-obituaries/7352232/Winston-Churchill.html>
as
late as 1978, when Prime Minister James Callaghan referenced "the vendetta
of your family against the miners of Tonypandy".

The riots had erupted in November 1910 in the south Wales town because of a
dispute between workers and the mine owners, culminating in strikes that
ultimately lasted almost a year.

When the strikers clashed with local police, Churchill - then home
secretary - sent in soldiers.

Allegations that shots were fired by the soldiers were unfounded, explains
Toye. In fact he'd sent a memo expressly denying that the use of violence
was a possibility.

Yet it made him a "pantomime villain" in the area ever since, Louise
Miskell, a historian at Swansea University, *told the BBC in March 2014*
<http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-wales-south-east-wales-26601738>.

But a year later *soldiers were again called in*
<http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-merseyside-14529243>, this time to
strike-related riots in Liverpool. On this occasion the soldiers did fire
their weapons and two people were killed.

And in later years his contempt for unions became more pronounced, says
Charmley.

In 1919, under Churchill, by now Secretary of State for Air and War, tanks
and an estimated 10,000 troops were deployed to Glasgow during a period of
widespread strikes and civil unrest amid fear of a Bolshevist revolt.

The Tonypandy incident is comparable to Margaret Thatcher's later struggles
with miners, Charmley suggests. One could argue that had Churchill not
moved in troops the situation could have been much worse and he would have
been criticised even more, he says.

*8. Sidney Street siege*

Not long after the Tonypandy Riots, Churchill was under fire for rash
involvement of a different sort.

The siege of Sidney Street was a gunfight in London's East End in January
1911. Some 200 police surrounded the hideout of a gang of Latvian
anarchists led by "Peter the Painter", who had killed three policemen the
month before.

Arthur Balfour told the Commons: "He and a photographer were both risking
valuable lives. I understand what the photographer was doing but what was
the right honourable gentleman doing?"

For Churchill's opponents it was an example of rashness and instability,
says Toye. A newsreel film *had caught him in the midst of the action*
<http://www.britishpathe.com/video/london-sidney-street-siege>.

*9. Role in Ireland*

In January 1919 Churchill assumed the role of Secretary of State for War
and Air. Eleven days later the Irish War of Independence began.

Churchill's role in Ireland is most associated with deploying the
controversial "Black and Tans" to fight the Irish Republican Army (IRA).
Named after their uniforms, these temporary constables soon developed a
reputation for excessive violence.

In Churchill: The Greatest Briton Unmasked, Nigel Knight claims that
Churchill repeatedly refused to stand down the Black and Tans and even
advocated the use of air power in Ireland.

But it would be unfair to label Churchill as anti-Irish, says Toye.

Although Churchill was against home rule for Ireland and initially
implemented harsh repression, he was also an early advocate of partition,
Toye explains. Churchill played a key role in the Anglo-Irish Treaty of
1921, which ended the war.

"It comes back to his character, which is: 'In war, resolution, in peace,
magnanimity'," says Packwood. "When he felt that there was a fight he would
push very hard [and] when he thought there was a chance of peace and
dialogue he was also at the forefront of that."

*10. Cash for influence*

"In return for a fee of £5,000 two oil companies, Royal Dutch Shell and
Burmah Anglo-Persian Oil Company [later BP], asked him to represent them in
their application to the government for a merger," Gilbert's official
biography stated. By modern British political standards, the 1923 payment
would be considered highly inappropriate. Churchill, whose "political
career was in the doldrums" at the time, according to a history of British
Petroleum, agreed to use his parliamentary influence to raise the issue in
return for money."But I'd be careful about calling it a bribe," Toye says.
"He accepted all sorts of gifts, which in today's culture of full
disclosure would get you expelled from the Commons. But those rules were
not in place at the time." The Register of Members' Interests was
introduced in 1975. "You can argue that it was a conflict of interest, you
can even argue that it was wrong, but you can't call it a bribe in the
sense that it was actually illegal," Toye says. "Politicians' links with
business and the media weren't under the same level of scrutiny as they
were then," says Packwood, "he was operating in a slightly different
ethical environment."

KR   IRS   14223

On Tue, 14 Feb 2023 at 01:05, 'N Sekar' via iyer123 <
[email protected]> wrote:

>
> Received from a friend
> N Sekar
>
> Who is the most evil killer of humanity - Adolf Hitler? or Winston
> Churchill?
>
> Of course none other than Winston Churchill  who was not a HERO  but a
> WITTY, EVIL, human creature.
>
> While Hitler and his Nazi cohorts took 12 years to round up and  murder 6
> million Jews on the basis of an absurd racist ideology, Racist Churchill
> took less than a year to gleefully kill between 4 to 5 million Indians.
>
> Churchill exported the entire bountiful harvest of Bengal to Europe and
> deliberately starve Eastern India. He adamantly turned down appeals from
> two successive Viceroys, his own Secretary of State for India and even the
> President of America to stop the holocaust.
>
> Unlike Hitler, slick historians and politicians of a victorious Britain
> glorified their own achievements and had Churchill duly glamorized and
> immortalized.
>
> Australian biochemist Dr.Gideon Polya  has called the Bengal Famine of
> 1943-44 a “ Man made Holocaust ”, the greatest disaster in the Indian
> subcontinent in the 20th century. Over 4 million Indians died because of an
> artificial famine engineered by Churchill's deliberate and direct policies".
>
> Areas comprising present-day West Bengal, Odisha, Bihar and Bangladesh had
> a bountiful harvest in 1942, but the British diverted vast quantities of
> food grain from India to Britain, contributing to a massive food shortage
> in these very areas.
>
> In her well researched book " Churchill's  Secrete War " author Madhusree
> Mukerjee   tracked down  some of the survivors and paints a chilling
> picture of the effects of Hunger and Deprivation.
>
> “ Parents dumped their starving children into rivers and wells. Many took
> their lives by throwing themselves in front of trains. Starving people
> begged for the starchy water in which rice had been boiled. Children ate
> leaves and vines, yam stems and grass. People were too weak even to cremate
> their loved ones.”
>
> “ No one had the strength to perform rites,”  a survivor told Mukerjee. “
> Dogs and jackals feasted on piles of dead bodies in Bengal’s villages.”
>
> The ones who got away were men who migrated to Calcutta for jobs and women
> who turned to prostitution to feed their families. “ Mothers had turned
> into murderers, village belles into whores, fathers into traffickers of
> daughters,”  writes Mukerjee.
>
> Mani Lal Bhaumik, the first person to get a PhD from the prestigious IITs
> and whose invention of Excimer Surgery enabled Lasik eye surgery, has the
> famine burnt into his memory. His grandmother starved to death because she
> used to give him a portion of her food.
>
> Legendary freedom fighter Subhash Chandra Bose, offered to send rice from
> Myanmar, but the British not only rejected the offer but censored news of
> Bose's offer.
>
>  All through this the legendary Freedom Fighters M.K.Gandhi and J.L.Nehru
> kept stoic silence on the Churchill engineered genocide but were exhorting
> Indians to contribute to the British war effects.
>
> Secretary of State for India and Burma, Leopold Amery, denounced Churchill
> and dubbed it  “Hitler-like attitude”.
>
> When the scale of the emerging Holocaust became known Amery and the then
> Viceroy Archibald Wavell fervently requested Churchill to release food
> stocks for India, Churchill  responded with a telegram asking  " Why has
> Gandhi not died as yet?".
>
> Churchill’s excuse, currently being peddled by his family and supporters,
> was Britain could not spare the ships to transport emergency supplies.
> However Mukerjee has unearthed documents that challenge this lie.
>
> She cites official records that reveal many ships carrying grain from
> Australia bypassed India on their way to the Mediterranean. Churchill could
> have saved millions of Indian lives but he chose not to.
>
> Churchill was a racist who hated Indians for every conceivable reason and
> mostly because Indians expressed their desire to be free.
>
> At a War Cabinet meeting, he blamed the Indians themselves for the famine,
> saying they “ Breed like Rabbits ”. His attitude toward Indians may be
> summed up in his words to Amery:
> "I hate Indians. They are a beastly people with beastly religions. ”
>
> The author Mike Davis in his award winning book " Late Victorian
> Holocausts " points out that that there were *31 serious famines in 120
> years of British rule compared with 17 in the 2,000 years before British
> rule.*
>
> 15 Million Indians died because of Colonial Genocide.. India's share went
> from 25% of global GDP in 1750 to 1.8% in 1947 (when the British left
> India).
>
> Some fools in our country who are still  arrogant, vocal but ignorant
> about real history try to convince others that British rule was a glorious
> period in Indian history. Nothing could be farther from the truth.
> Inexplicably these enslaved Indian minds still pine  for their former
> British masters.
> --
>
> *A.Suryanarayana*
> *Great minds have purposes, others have wishes*
> --
>
> *A.Suryanarayana*
> *Great minds have purposes, others have wishes*
>
> --
> You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups
> "iyer123" group.
> To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an
> email to [email protected].
> To view this discussion on the web visit
> https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/iyer123/1115478951.1130195.1676365526688%40mail.yahoo.com
> <https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/iyer123/1115478951.1130195.1676365526688%40mail.yahoo.com?utm_medium=email&utm_source=footer>
> .
>

-- 
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
"Thatha_Patty" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email 
to [email protected].
To view this discussion on the web visit 
https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/thatha_patty/CAL5XZopBChbE_FzhZHFbufSm5D7XMruoStLmzP-ux-gfT2YxVg%40mail.gmail.com.

Reply via email to