On 10/29/2010 08:28 PM, WarrenS wrote:
If it is time to come back from all the "Dead" subjects, I have a time
nut question.
What is the correct 100 sec Allan value of this low noise 10811 Osc? All
plots are of the same OSC, just different parts of the same data run.
None of them is correct, but the Overlapping 0K-563K curve is closest to
the real curve, if only drift is compensated for. However, for the run
you have here, drift does not dominate so no real drift needs to be
compensated.
What you have is typical and really shows that the statistical
confidence bounds can be very bad for longer taus using the Allan
variance estimator... even the overlapping one.
The relative closeness of the various curves up to about 1 second comes
from the richness of observables, or high degree of freedom. As the tau
becomes higher the degrees of freedom falls like a stone and the
statistical confidence intervals just blows out.
There is two basic cures for this, more data, better estimator or better
yet, both.
The research for better estimators is motivated by the need to improve
the quality (confidence intervals) without having very long measurement
series. The overlapping estimator is really the first step of
improvement of estimator, but certainly not the last. Modern estimators
such as the Theo variants cranks out more degrees of freedom from the
same sequence of samples and thus will have better confidence intervals
and this moves the point where the confidence intervals blows up to
higher taus, but it will happen eventually.
So, of the measures you have, the full-length overlapping is the best in
that set.
I had to read up a lot when I put some time on getting the Wikipedia
article on Allan Variance into better shape. It was darn good exercise.
I still have a few aspects to cover in that article, but I haven't had
the time.
Cheers,
Magnus
_______________________________________________
time-nuts mailing list -- time-nuts@febo.com
To unsubscribe, go to https://www.febo.com/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/time-nuts
and follow the instructions there.
