Hello Nick (and all other) >From the beginning I were not impressed at all of your design as you started >with a 100ns resolution TIC and a FLL. I compared it to the BG7TBL design. The >only benefit your design had was that it was open source. But your design has >got better and better and you took help from others.
I have no problem you have ”stolen” the phase detector design from me. I have no intention at all to make it commercial as you have done. Of course due credits to relevant persons are always good. For the TIC I don’t believe in the JFET but the bipolar variant from JimH might work but of course you have to do the home work for variations and stability, also Jim indicates some other problems. As Bruce give hint of a simple RC design as my may be easier to linearize as I have done. I will probably comment more on this. For the DAC I think my PWM with 16 bits works fine for a DIY but for a commercial GPSDO I would go for something like the Stanford to get 20-22bits. But I have also long ago looked at the AD5680 that is reasonable cheap for a monotonic 18 bit DAC. Lars ________________________________ Från: time-nuts <time-nuts-boun...@lists.febo.com> för Nick Sayer via time-nuts <time-nuts@lists.febo.com> Skickat: Friday, September 7, 2018 10:38:31 PM Till: Discussion of precise time and frequency measurement Kopia: Nick Sayer Ämne: Re: [time-nuts] PLL/GPSDO/etc learning resources for mere mortals I’d like to thank Jim and Lars both publicly for that design - I quite shamelessly stole the phase detector for my own GPSDO gizmos. Jim at one point suggested adding a JFET to make the pulse with to voltage curve more linear, but that probably doesn’t make all that much difference. On my 5660 controller, there is no DAC - you send digital commands to affect the EFC. For my OCXO I use an 18 bit DAC compressed somewhat into the most useful part of the XO’s EFC range. My project page on hackaday is at https://hackaday.io/project/6872-gps-disciplined-xcxo > On Sep 7, 2018, at 12:25 PM, Lars Walenius <lars.walen...@hotmail.com> wrote: > > I heard Jim mentioned my GPSDO. I would not go to the time nuts archive as > that describes a far from ready software design. The hardware is almost > identical. Last year I published a new design on EEVBlog: > > https://www.eevblog.com/forum/projects/lars-diy-gpsdo-with-arduino-and-1ns-resolution-tic/?all > > This is a, as I think, a much more robust design and much more tested. By > just setting the”gain” it will make a stable 1Hz digital PLL. As the DAC can > be set and you have a counter with 1ns resolution you don’t need any extra > instruments to do this. The nice thing is that the controller is very > flexible and can handle all kinds of 10MHz oscillators as XO, TCXO, OXCO and > rubidium. The useful control range of the oscillators is 0.001-6ppm. As only > a 1PPS with 3.3-5V amplitude is needed a wide variation of GPS modules can be > used. The time constant can be set from 4 to 32000 seconds and stored in > EEPROM. > > In the 21 pages of instruction I describe the design and also give > performance data as both a GPSDO and a time interval counter. As Jim says my > GPSDO gives useful information how you can do your own GPSDO. On the first > pages I have some discussion of the GPS modules like NEO7M that can be used > and also about different oscillators. Note I think the oscillators are the > first you should think of as they set the most important specs for the GPSDO. > See also the user manual for Stanford FS740 that contains a lot of > information about a modern GPSDO. Here the link to Stanford FS740 seems to be > broken in my instruction. Today this worked: > https://www.thinksrs.com/downloads/pdfs/manuals/FS740m.pdf See for example > pages 25-35 for a good description of the GPSDO part. In the end of the > manual you also find complete schematics! > > On pages 8-9 in my instruction you find a very short description of my > software and it is a standard PI-loop with a low pass filter before just as > in the FS740. Paul-Henning has a very simple introduction to the PI-loop that > I like http://phk.freebsd.dk/time/20141018.html . I would also recommend > learning from the GPSDO simulator by Tom Van Baak > http://www.leapsecond.com/pages/gpsdo-sim/ it also uses a PI-loop + low > pass filter and his code tells you a lot. > > From Tom’s GPSDO simulator you can also learn how the time resolution and the > DAC resolution work with real time data. Magnus Danielsson in March 2014 > published the result of some his simulations with different time and DAC > resolutions on time nuts. My takeaway was that a time resolution below 5-10ns > was ok and DAC resolutions in the ballpark of the oscillator ADEV was fine, > but have a look on his data. > > On page 15 in my instruction you find a list of basic links that I have found > useful. Some links seems broken so for example for Stanford’s you have to > find again on their homepage. > > On pages 16-17 you find help commands and description of serial information. > By the way Mark Sims excellent LH can read this and use the time, DAC and > temperature data that are spit out every second > http://www.eevblog.com/forum/metrology/lady-heather-v6-beta-for-windows-exe/?all > . This together with the GPS module of choice serial output data should > make this very useful. I am sorry I haven’t used this as I am very weak of > chemo and haven’t done anything to my GPSDO for a long time. > > Page 18 shows setup to read for example DAC data into Timelab. > > On page 19 you find some ADEV results of two of my prototype GPSDO’s. One > with a TCXO DOT050V and one with a OCXO 131(that by purpose uses a bad DAC > resolution of 1.2E-11 but still gets ADEV’s in the 5E-12 range. > > Last two pages show data with the controller used as a time interval counter. > By measuring the TIC with a PICDIV PD26 it is possible to enter a few > linearization parameters in EEPROM and get ADEV’s in the 8E-10 range at 1sec. > > Even if I don’t recommend reading specific about my GPSDO on time nuts I > really recommend to search and read the time nuts archive. It is a lot of > useful information and a special thank to Bob kb8tq who contributes with so > much valuable information. After I published the GPSDO on time nuts I also > got good help from Jim H with the hardware interrupt in the ATmega328. With > the hardware interrupt the 200ns resolution on timer 1 works well with a > jitter of just 40ns p-p. TvB also gave the idea to set the timer1 to an > factor that suits the input frequency that in this case is 5Mhz so I choose > 50000(-1) (instead of 65536-1). This gives overflow at 10ms and is easy to > handle. I could probably thank a lot more people for good advises. > > Lars > > Ps. Note that Lars GPSDO is more a 10MHz frequency reference, not a time > reference and by that I mean it has no jitter free PPS out. This can be added > by external hardware. > > > > > > ________________________________ > Från: time-nuts <time-nuts-boun...@lists.febo.com> för Jim Harman > <j99har...@gmail.com> > Skickat: Tuesday, September 4, 2018 6:28:00 PM > Till: Discussion of precise time and frequency measurement > Ämne: Re: [time-nuts] PLL/GPSDO/etc learning resources for mere mortals > >> The challenge seems to me to be > > how to temperature stabilize the entire DAC chain without putting it all in > an oven > > Hi Forrest, > > Generally you don't have to temperature stabilize the DAC because it is > inside the phase-locked control loop and the loop will adjust for > temperature dependencies, just as it adjusts for drift and temperature > dependencies in the oscillator. You will want your phase detector to be > reasonably temperature stable however. > > In the time-nuts archives you will find posts from Lars Walenius and myself > with schematics and code for Arduino-based GPSDOs which you might want to > study. > _______________________________________________ > time-nuts mailing list -- time-nuts@lists.febo.com > To unsubscribe, go to > http://lists.febo.com/mailman/listinfo/time-nuts_lists.febo.com > and follow the instructions there. > <Minimum working schematic for GPSDO controller > 170629a.jpg>_______________________________________________ > time-nuts mailing list -- time-nuts@lists.febo.com > To unsubscribe, go to > http://lists.febo.com/mailman/listinfo/time-nuts_lists.febo.com > and follow the instructions there. _______________________________________________ time-nuts mailing list -- time-nuts@lists.febo.com To unsubscribe, go to http://lists.febo.com/mailman/listinfo/time-nuts_lists.febo.com and follow the instructions there. _______________________________________________ time-nuts mailing list -- time-nuts@lists.febo.com To unsubscribe, go to http://lists.febo.com/mailman/listinfo/time-nuts_lists.febo.com and follow the instructions there.
