As I understand, 3 cornered hat is nothing more than system of equations where
you have 3 variables and 3 equations, that allows for solving for each. I'm
going to hold off on that one. I forgot about thermal and equipment's internal
noise. It all makes sense. I hope to be doing some measuring this weekend if
all works as planned (hope, hope, hope....)
I mentioned earlier, I have various standards. I also have TAPR's board to
create 1 pps from any standards I have. To start and follow your last example
on how-to, what would you recommend for DUT and the standard? I'd like to do
one that I can show you, and immediately say if it's what you'd expect or not.
I have newly repaired HP105B, PRS10, Efratom FRK-c?, LPRO-101, and various
GPSDO including T-bolt proper. For the counter, I think I'll use the old HP
interval counter, rather than 50132A. The latter is all menu driven. It's so
easy to mis-set or otherwise screw it up and not notice it. HP5370A is all
switches and knobs. How long of measurement? In my experience, 2 days will
show the inflection point.
---------------------------------------
(Mr.) Taka Kamiya
KB4EMF / ex JF2DKG
On Saturday, February 22, 2020, 3:03:37 AM EST, Magnus Danielson via
time-nuts <time-nuts@lists.febo.com> wrote:
Hi Taka,
On 2020-02-22 04:55, Taka Kamiya via time-nuts wrote:
> It's not like drinking from a fire hydrant. It's like drowning in hoover
> dam, get sucked into an inlet, pulverized by turbine blade, and getting spit
> out into a stream.
Hmm, not exactly what I had hoped for as your experience... whatever,
hope it is worth it.
>
> One question :
>
> You said this:
> "The resolution of your counter tells you about where your 1/tau curve
> will cut tau = 1 s, and it goes from there. There is a slight scaling
> factor, but if we assume it is 1 for now, it is pretty simple. Your
> 5335A has 1 ns single-shot resolution, this gives 1E-9 at 1 s, but 1E-10
> at 10 s, 1E-11 at 100 s and 1E-12 at 1000 s. You see very clearly when
> the linear slope ends and "lands" in the noise, at which time the noise
> becomes dominant and is giving you the interesting reading."
> By using the same logic, I can keep going up and up on longer gate time and
> tau keeps getting better and better. I know at one point, inflection happens
> and that indicates noise taking over. But what kind of noise (phase?) and
> how does that happen?
OK. Good question.
The instrument noise in itself can be while phase noise and flicker
phase noise. The resolution limit will be a systematic disturbance. All
these three has the same 1/tau slope so from these three, nothing
happens as tau increases. At some point naturally will thermal
instability come in, but that will be another systematic, but it will be
hard to cancel. So that is the limit of the instrument.
However, the noise of the reference and DUT will dominate for larger
taus, and thus it will be good enough to measure that noise. Besides,
length of measurement becomes a limit.
> Only thing that changes in this equation is the gate time. Everything is
> constant. You mean gate time is no longer accurate enough to support the
> minute shift in phase?
> I'm still confused about the precision (not accuracy) of the time base. Am I
> still ultimately constrained by this?
There are ways to get around it.
> Without DMTD, or some kind of pre-scaling of DUT, if I measure Rb with time
> base using another Rb, they are both rubber-bands, correct?
Now, what you can do is to do a three-cornered hat measurement.
Essentially you measure three sources at once as three pair-wise
measurements. You calculate your ADEV of each pair. Now, as you have the
noises n1, n2 and n3 of each source, measurement m1 = n1+n2, m2 = n1+n3
and m3 = n2+n3. This equation problem can be solved to bring out n1, n2
and n3 separate. The trouble is, this does not always work out as
precisely as one would like, because the measurements isn't precise and
well converged. Therefore it is a bit of sensitive process, but if one
gets it working, you can achieve the separation.
> I'm infinitely curious by nature. I need to know everything, even to a
> minute detail, to be satisfied. I hope you don't get tired of this.
So far, you ask relevant questions that can be given an answer. Being a
curious person myself, I've digged down.
Cheers,
Magnus
_______________________________________________
time-nuts mailing list -- time-nuts@lists.febo.com
To unsubscribe, go to
http://lists.febo.com/mailman/listinfo/time-nuts_lists.febo.com
and follow the instructions there.
_______________________________________________
time-nuts mailing list -- time-nuts@lists.febo.com
To unsubscribe, go to
http://lists.febo.com/mailman/listinfo/time-nuts_lists.febo.com
and follow the instructions there.
