Jean-Sebastien Delfino wrote:
[snip]

Another problem is all our bindings work differently. So <binding.ws/>, <
> binding.rmi/> <binding.jms/> <binding.jsonrpc/> etc all result in a
> service
> being available at a different endpoint. Also the uri attribute on those
>
> bindings all work differently so uri="foo" for some bindings would be
> treated as relative uri, for others an absolute one. What we need is a
> bit
> of code that implements section 1.7.2.1 of the assembly spec which all
> bindings then use. (a generic version of
> Axis2ServiceProvider.computeActualURI). Didn't this come up once before
> and
> something was changing in the runtime binding for this?


I think that these URIs should be determined as part of the process of combining wires and uris specified at different levels in the SCA assembly. If the correct URIs are determined once as part of this process, a binding provider should be able to just call binding.getURI(), without having to calculate it at all, on its own or even calling a central URI calculator method.


Before trying to implement a common algorithm for all bindings, I thought I'd double check the various SCA spec docs. Here's what I found:

- WebService binding
absolute URI specified in binding/@uri
or
base domain URI for http: + '/' + component URI + '/' + relative URI specified in binding/@uri
or
absolute URI specified in WSDL
or
base domain URI for http: + '/' + component URI + '/' + relative URI specified in WSDL
or
absolute URI specified in a wsa:Address
or
base domain URI for http: + '/' + component URI + '/' + relative URI specified in a wsa:Address

- JMS binding
JMS specific URI specified in binding/@uri
or
no URI, combination of JMS specific attributes

- EJB binding
base domain URI for corba:iiop: + '#' + relative URI specified in binding/@uri
or
base domain URI for corba:rir: + '#' + relative URI specified in binding/@uri
or
absolute URI specified in binding/@uri

I think that other bindings introduced by Tuscany can follow similar patterns:

- RMI binding
similar to EJB binding

- JSON, Ajax and Feed bindings
absolute URI specified in binding/@uri
or
base domain URI for http: + '/' + component URI + '/' + relative URI specified in binding/@uri

Thoughts? could you guys please review to make sure I understood the specs correctly? Thanks.

--
Jean-Sebastien


---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to