"Eduardo Vieira" <eduardo.su...@gmail.com> wrote
....I simply decided to alter the code as little as
possible and use the import statement. It's working this way. Sounds wise?

Its an acceptab;e approach bwhen you are doing exactly the same thing, but its not a very flexible approach and leaves you very vulnerable if you get a change that only applies to one of your solutions.


I thought if I converted it to a function or a class would make
it more flexible,

A set of functions is probably sufficient from the sounds of things. That way you can mix n match the functions, pass in different arguments etc to get the same functionality but with more control.

functions out of everything. I'm still too much attached to
procedural, not functional programming, if I understand the terms
correctly.

procedural programming is where you use procedures or functions to accomplish the task. You link those functions together, either in a top level function or in global level cotrol script. This is also (more correctly) known as imperative style programming.

functional programming is quite different and comprises a set of rules about how the code should be structured. In functional programming the whole program is a function that returns a value. Every function should return a value and functions should not alter any global data. Every function should ideally be an expression. No stateful constructs such as loops or assignment statements should be used (repetition is done via recursion). In practice most folks relax the rules a little and allow simple loops (ie using a counter as in
for n in range(n))

and some assignments. But the ideal is to build a program with no state and everything done as an expression with nested sub expressions. It is very closely aligned with formal methods in Computer Science and formal languages such as Z or VDM

For most programmers functional programming is at least as big a conceptual leap from procedural or imperative programming as OOP.

I'll comment on the code separately.


--
Alan Gauld
Author of the Learn to Program web site
http://www.alan-g.me.uk/

_______________________________________________
Tutor maillist  -  Tutor@python.org
http://mail.python.org/mailman/listinfo/tutor

Reply via email to