There is absolutely no war existing and only good practice is realty as it is for the benefit of the customers. "Inspire to share". I still remember the day I started to promote cooluri as on this day no autoconfig was existing in realurl and many people beside me had problems to set it up. This was one of the reasons actually why cooluri made its way. Months later the autoconfig for realurl has been released, a great feature which was very good for standard sites. Now we had a very easy to write XML file with a great Backend management and we had autoconfiguration - ok with a bit difficult to modify afterwards configuration files if use serialized. Unfortunately it is still not possible to combine the power of both extensions until now. It really depends on the situation what to use is good or not as good.
People often look hours and days and more to solve a problem while with a simple change to another extension this problem would have been solved quite easily or even won't exist. This is why we use both extensions according the specific needs of the customers. In a TYPOgento site i.e. we use realurl as you only need to install it and it is working as long as you have only one language which is non asian. In another we use cooluri because we needed the asian languages get running which we achieved much easier in cooluri, also the customer wanted to have all the ending parts striped away, which seems now to be possible with the version of realurl in svn too. Searching for problems and reinventing wheels costs often lots of time, while a working solution - but perhaps with another extension - is already existing. Security issues have been in many extensions - important is that they get fixed fast and those sql injections in cooluri are fixed since 2009. http://secunia.com/advisories/search/?search=typo3+cooluri Since than the cooluri code has been improved also a lot and new features have been implemented! The same realurl has been improved a lot. Meanwhile the autocnfiguration seems to recognize also language settings (but unfortunaetely not Japanese or Thai). The main problem with all those extensions which try to "inspire to share" each other, often just achieve the opposite. They cost a whole lot of time to setup, configure or integrate, searching in mailinglists, manage while if they simply would take both of two worlds together in one solid concept than everyone would have a solution which probably would work just out of the box with no further configuration and would be part of the TYPO3 core with a small checkbox asking you ... do you want nice looking URLs? yes/no Perhaps Dmitry and Jan should get together with some other interested URL-Coiffeurs and get THE TYPO3 Clean URL solution up and running for TYPO3 4.6. and afterwards we would have a solution with Click and all your URLs and of all TYPO3 extensions would instantly produce nice looking URLs. Unfortunately we seem to be still far away from this nice vision, but we should never give up hope - or :-) Andi <http://secunia.com/advisories/search/?search=typo3+cooluri> On Thu, Mar 24, 2011 at 10:40 PM, Dmitry Dulepov <[email protected]>wrote: > Hi! > > > Tobias Dörner wrote: > >> Hi Dimtry, Jan and Andreas, >> about<offtopic>make peace not war ^^</offtopic> >> > > No war :) It happens so that Jan (and sometimes Andreas) come to the > RealURL threads and post something like "Use coolURI instead", which is > neither on topic, nor it gives any answers to the user's question. I > consider it bad practice. But if Jan does that, I would probably follow and > do the same to balance his posts with mine in CoolURI threads :) Than we can > agree not to post useless stuff in threads dedicated to each other's > extensions. > > No war :) > > > -- > Dmitry Dulepov > TYPO3 core&security team member > E-mail: [email protected] > Web: http://dmitry-dulepov.com/ > _______________________________________________ > TYPO3-english mailing list > [email protected] > http://lists.typo3.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/typo3-english > _______________________________________________ TYPO3-english mailing list [email protected] http://lists.typo3.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/typo3-english
