On 2026-03-06 11:39, Paul Eggert via tz wrote:
On 2026-03-06 08:11, Robert Bastian via tz wrote:
Because CLDR keys its display names by this flag, this change will cause ICU and
other downstream software (including major operating systems) to display
BC’s UTC-7 as "Pacific Standard Time," while Los Angeles’ UTC-7 will
display as "Pacific Daylight Time."
Maintenance releases of ICU 78.3 and CLDR 48.2 are scheduled for this month, so
it seems unlikely that anythng to do with these changes could make it in.
Major releases ICU 79 and CLDR 49 are planned for October and could incorporate
changes required, including those to TZ DB.
Yes, and what's currently in the draft TZDB on GitHub (America/Vancouver
switching to abbreviation "-07") was intended to be merely a placeholder. We
weren't intending to publish it as 2026b.
For the reason you mention and for other software-compatibility reasons, let's
change the "-07" placeholder to an alphabetic abbreviation. The simplest fix
appears to be to change to the abbreviation "MST", as is already the case for
America/Vancouver's geographic neighbors that observe UTC-7 all year. This
should fix the CLDR issue (albeit in a different way than what you suggested),
and should be good enough until the BC government and/or common practice advises
us all later on what three-or-more-character abbreviation is most popular.
Of course we'd prefer to make just one change now, and no changes later, but it
seems we do not have that luxury given the rushed way this was done legally. And
I would rather publish something before the actual legal change occurs on
Monday, rather than issue a post-facto change.
That would likely be a divergence from the expectation and requirement that time
remains P[D]T, until other libraries and systems have a chance to catch up for
November, and only then will any change in time zone be obvious, especially as
most devices (phones) will then show MST, compatible with Yukon and eastern BC
regions following AB time, rather than PT or anything similar.
ISTM that if you want enable apps and systems to display anything other than TZ
DB ids, you have to allow adequate time for those changes to be planned,
implemented, and distributed, when possible.
Otherwise you will be encouraging downstreams to use the TZ DB ids to provide
quick results, with possibly consequent flurries of complaints from downstreams,
users, and demands from irate politicians and provincial government officials,
who ignored the requirement for adequate prior notice and consultation with the
local/summer time keeping global community on here.
I would also urge Alberta politicians, who are once again talking about pushing
our time zone further east, or who knows what may be in their tiny minds this
time, to have provincial government officials get in touch here for guidance,
before the October referendum, on which they are now talking about including a
question about the summer time issue.
Otherwise they risk any ill considered ideas being ignored, and popping up on
their phones different from their plans, as appears likely with BC time.
--
Take care. Thanks, Brian Inglis Calgary, Alberta, Canada
La perfection est atteinte Perfection is achieved
non pas lorsqu'il n'y a plus rien à ajouter not when there is no more to add
mais lorsqu'il n'y a plus rien à retrancher but when there is no more to cut
-- Antoine de Saint-Exupéry