After reviewing this thread's discussion, the consensus is to delay the tm_isdst transition as requested, so I installed the attached proposed further patch after talking with Tim. This patch contains a temporary workaround for America/Vancouver timestamps between March 9 and November 1 of this year. The workaround should accommodate CLDR's current limitation, by marking these timestamps with tm_isdst as requested. The plan is to remove the temporary workaround once CLDR is updated to remove the limitation, which as I understand it can be done by a CLDR release before November.

Although not affecting CLDR, this patch also replaces the "-07" placeholder abbreviation with "MST". No abbreviation choice is ideal here, but "MST" appears to be the best of a bad lot. This abbreviation can be updated once we find out what common practice does with three-or-more-letter abbreviations.

This patch removes any need for a TZDB release in the next couple of days, as TZDB's proposed March 9 entry is now effectively a no-op and there is no user-visible change in America/Vancouver's behavior until November. However, we do need a new TZDB release sooner rather than later because that November change must be user-visible, and TZDB changes can take time to propagate to devices regardless of whether the devices also use CLDR. So I'm thinking we wait for further comments and release TZDB 2026b in a couple of weeks, or April at the latest - unless some unrelated and more urgent data change comes up, in case we can simply release.

This episode is a bit of a wakeup call for the coordination between TZDB and CLDR. Although in the past we've lucked out with similar changes in Yukon and elsewhere, we will likely not be so lucky in plausible future changes to timekeeping in North America, the EU, and other places where people are considering abolishing DST transitions and changing time zones and time zone names. Yesterday's email from Brian Inglis[1] suggested that CLDR won't be able to accommodate the America/Vancouver change until October, but I hope that's overly pessimistic as it will surely take considerable time for the CLDR change's effects to be shaken out in applications, and users will need to deal with timestamps planned for November and later well before November rolls around.

In short, the process for updating TZDB + CLDR surely can use more streamlining.

[1]: https://lists.iana.org/hyperkitty/list/[email protected]/message/BRP7ONFZU42SFR4TNRUWBBKOSVBBUCEN/
From 8e7dcafc27d697c51dda77bb8804d62eda033c04 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001
From: Paul Eggert <[email protected]>
Date: Sat, 7 Mar 2026 00:11:29 -0800
Subject: [PROPOSED] Delay America/Vancouver tm_isdst transition

Requested for CLDR by Robert Bastian in:
https://lists.iana.org/hyperkitty/list/[email protected]/thread/IEZR4HYQXZTUMGRA7FEZJAKAOGFGOPIP/
Also, use "MST" rather than "-07" as the abbreviation.
* NEWS: Adjust accordingly.
* northamerica (America/Vancouver): As a temporary hack, model the
change as occurring on 2026-11-01 02:00, not on 2026-03-09.
Also, use "MST" rather than "-07".
* zone.tab, zone1970.tab, zonenow.tab: Adjust comments accordingly.
---
 NEWS         | 11 +++++++----
 northamerica | 29 +++++++++++++++++++++--------
 zone.tab     |  2 +-
 zone1970.tab |  2 +-
 zonenow.tab  |  4 ++--
 5 files changed, 32 insertions(+), 16 deletions(-)

diff --git a/NEWS b/NEWS
index 3ed61963..267e62da 100644
--- a/NEWS
+++ b/NEWS
@@ -4,10 +4,13 @@ Unreleased, experimental changes
 
   Changes to future timestamps
 
-    On 2026-03-09 British Columbia will go from daylight to standard
-    time, without a UT offset change.  That is, its 2026-03-08 spring
-    forward will be its last foreseeable clock change, as it will move
-    to permanent -07 thereafter.  (Thanks to Arthur David Olson.)
+    British Columbia's 2026-03-08 spring forward will be its last
+    foreseeable clock change, as it moves to permanent -07 thereafter.
+    (Thanks to Arthur David Olson.)  Although the change to permanent
+    -07 legally takes place on 2026-03-09, temporarily model the
+    change to occur on 2026-11-01 at 02:00 instead.  This works around
+    a limitation in CLDR v48.1 (2026-01-08).  This temporary hack is
+    planned to be removed after CLDR is fixed.
 
 
 Release 2026a - 2026-03-01 22:59:49 -0800
diff --git a/northamerica b/northamerica
index 815fda14..ee0dc50a 100644
--- a/northamerica
+++ b/northamerica
@@ -1962,22 +1962,32 @@ Zone America/Edmonton	-7:33:52 -	LMT	1906 Sep
 # on March 8 will be the last time change, ending twice-yearly clock changes.”
 # https://news.gov.bc.ca/releases/2026AG0013-000209
 #
-# From Paul Eggert (2026-03-03):
-# The law specifies a 2026-03-08 02:00 switch from PST to PDT, then 21 hours
-# of PDT, then a 2026-03-09 switch to the new standard time Pacific Time,
+# From Paul Eggert (2026-03-07):
+# The law says that 21 hours after the usual 2026-03-08 02:00 switch from
+# PST to PDT, the next day inaugurates the new standard time Pacific Time,
 # i.e., just one clock change but two name changes separated by 21 hours.
-#
 # PT, the obvious abbreviation for Pacific Time, is one letter too short
 # to conform to TZDB’s (and POSIX’s) [-+[:alnum:]]{3,6} requirements.
-# I asked the BC government for advice, with no response yet.
-# For now, use the abbreviation -07; we can decide later what (if any)
-# conforming non-numeric abbreviation to use.  Possibilities include:
+# I asked the BC government for advice, with no response. For now, do this:
+#   1.	As a temporary hack, pretend that the BC law takes effect
+#	not on 2026-03-09 at 00:00, but on 2026-11-01 at 02:00.
+#	This pretense works around a limitation in CLDR v48.1 (2026-01-08),
+#	which would otherwise say the interval uses “Pacific Standard Time”.
+#	(Below, this temporary hack is marked “Temporary hack; see above.”)
+#	Strictly speaking this hack is incorrect since the interval uses
+#	standard time, but it does have the right UT offset and it
+#	works around the CLDR limitation.  We should be able to remove
+#	the temporary hack after CLDR is fixed.
+#   2.	After the BC law takes effect, model the time as MST sans DST.
+#	We can change this later if another conforming non-numeric abbreviation
+#	for Pacific Time becomes more popular.  Possibilities include:
 #   MST - the most compatible with existing software and practice,
 #	and already used in parts of BC and in Yukon
 #   PDT - almost as software-friendly, but confusing because it implies
 #	it is DST and is paired with PST, whereas PT is standard time
 #   PST - straightforward but even more confusing,
 #	and will likely break much software that assumes PST is -08
+#   -07 - accurate and clear in itself, but makes BC look odd vs neighbors
 #   CPT, CPST - for Canadian Pacific (Standard) Time,
 #	by analogy with AEST in Australia
 #   P-T - conforming approximation to “PT”
@@ -1997,7 +2007,10 @@ Rule	Vanc	1962	2006	-	Oct	lastSun	2:00	0	S
 Zone America/Vancouver	-8:12:28 -	LMT	1884
 			-8:00	Vanc	P%sT	1987
 			-8:00	Canada	P%sT	2026 Mar  9
-			-7:00	-	-07
+			# Temporary hack; see above.
+			-8:00	1:00	PDT	2026 Nov  1 02:00
+			# End of temporary hack.
+			-7:00	-	MST
 Zone America/Dawson_Creek -8:00:56 -	LMT	1884
 			-8:00	Canada	P%sT	1947
 			-8:00	Vanc	P%sT	1972 Aug 30  2:00
diff --git a/zone.tab b/zone.tab
index 2626b055..d74dfd86 100644
--- a/zone.tab
+++ b/zone.tab
@@ -129,7 +129,7 @@ CA	+5546-12014	America/Dawson_Creek	MST - BC (Dawson Cr, Ft St John)
 CA	+5848-12242	America/Fort_Nelson	MST - BC (Ft Nelson)
 CA	+6043-13503	America/Whitehorse	MST - Yukon (east)
 CA	+6404-13925	America/Dawson	MST - Yukon (west)
-CA	+4916-12307	America/Vancouver	Pacific - BC (most areas)
+CA	+4916-12307	America/Vancouver	British Columbia (most areas)
 CC	-1210+09655	Indian/Cocos
 CD	-0418+01518	Africa/Kinshasa	Dem. Rep. of Congo (west)
 CD	-1140+02728	Africa/Lubumbashi	Dem. Rep. of Congo (east)
diff --git a/zone1970.tab b/zone1970.tab
index cd43e3d2..104c3efe 100644
--- a/zone1970.tab
+++ b/zone1970.tab
@@ -119,7 +119,7 @@ CA	+5546-12014	America/Dawson_Creek	MST - BC (Dawson Cr, Ft St John)
 CA	+5848-12242	America/Fort_Nelson	MST - BC (Ft Nelson)
 CA	+6043-13503	America/Whitehorse	MST - Yukon (east)
 CA	+6404-13925	America/Dawson	MST - Yukon (west)
-CA	+4916-12307	America/Vancouver	Pacific - BC (most areas)
+CA	+4916-12307	America/Vancouver	British Columbia (most areas)
 CH,DE,LI	+4723+00832	Europe/Zurich	Büsingen
 CI,BF,GH,GM,GN,IS,ML,MR,SH,SL,SN,TG	+0519-00402	Africa/Abidjan
 CK	-2114-15946	Pacific/Rarotonga
diff --git a/zonenow.tab b/zonenow.tab
index 76465722..9f01a9f9 100644
--- a/zonenow.tab
+++ b/zonenow.tab
@@ -58,8 +58,8 @@ XX	-2504-13005	Pacific/Pitcairn	Pitcairn
 # -08/-07 - PST/PDT (North America DST)
 XX	+340308-1181434	America/Los_Angeles	Pacific (PST/PDT) - US & Canada; Mexico near US border
 #
-# -08/-07 - PST/PDT (British Columbia DST) until 2026-03-09; then -07
-XX	+4916-12307	America/Vancouver	Pacific - BC (most areas)
+# -08/-07 - PST/PDT (North America DST) until 2026-11-01 02:00; then MST
+XX	+4916-12307	America/Vancouver	British Columbia (most areas)
 #
 # -07 - MST
 XX	+332654-1120424	America/Phoenix	Mountain Standard (MST) - Arizona; western Mexico; Yukon
-- 
2.51.0

Reply via email to