On 2026-11-02 03:41 PM, James Bellaire wrote:
The Sunshine Protection Act will not pass the Senate without
amendment. The "Cruz amendment" accepted by the Senate committee last
year when the committee approved the Senate version sets an effective
date TWO YEARS after passage. Plenty of notice.
While there are examples of short notice changes in US history, this
is not likely to be one of them.
The Senate does need to amend the Cruz amendment if voted on this
year. We would not want a fall back November 4th 2028 followed by a
spring forward in November or December.
Or start over in January with the next Congress.
I am hoping that Senator Cotton allows a floor vote just so we can
see it pass or fail by vote instead of being blocked by political
maneuvering.
PS: I Voted two weeks ago for the election tomorrow.
I'm aware of the Cruz amendment to the Sunshine Protection Act (SPA).
Hopefully that will further delay passage because they'll have to vote
on the amendment before they can vote on the Act.
But the date of its going into effect is hardly the worst aspect of the SPA.
As discussed on the list, the SPA presents irreconcilable logical
conflicts with TzDb and POSIX name abbreviations. While many aspects of
DST have been debated, from energy saving, to retail hours, to sleep
patterns, the technical complexities have been entirely overlooked. This
will be expensive development and is potentially dangerous. How to
inform the lawmakers and the public about these issues is a challenge.
The SPA changes critical terms of the Calder act of 1918 and the Uniform
Time Act of 1966. These laws have been at the foundation of timekeeping
in the USA for decades. Altering them changes the very definition of
time, legal time, likely with many unintended consequences.
Permanent daylight saving has sunset an hour later, but sunrise is also
delayed. This is the "kids in the dark in the morning" issue, the reason
the H.R.11324 - Emergency Daylight Saving Time Energy Conservation Act
of 1973
was repealed in 1974 (H.R.15874 - A bill to repeal the Emergency
Daylight Saving Time Energy Conservation Act of 1973)
There is currently a bill in the House to make standard time permanent:
H.R. 9638: Sunshine for Our Kids Act of 2026
https://www.govtrack.us/congress/bills/119/hr9638
Permanent standard time is much better technically. It's simple for TzDb
to stop DST and those changes propagate easily through downstream
systems: It is also the most natural daylight which has several
beneficial effects. But society would have to make many adjustments to
scheduling.
I wonder if both both these bills violate Federalism. Could they be
challenged as unconstitutional?
As I understand it the States have the option of observing DST or not.
If they were to all agree to permanent standard time and simultaneously
put it in effect we could finally be rid of DST. But that would take a
very long campaign.
Much as I'd like to see DST go away and think permanent standard time is
the best option, I think the status quo, observing DST as we have for
decades, is the only safe path.
-Brooks