Hi Torsten, > here is the requested resend of the first mini-series with the fixes, > now hopefully with all interested people involved. I regenerated it > using get_maintainer.pl on part1 and part2, for the heads-up. > I also added Oleksii's refreshed review tag. > > Part2 takes actually longer to rework than expected; documentation on the > PCIe bridges is not so opulent, mildly speaking. > > This set should apply cleanly on 2025.10 and on master [1c250e444ad].
So generally these all need more work. To begin with the commit messages in general, as well as the proper sign offs and attributions, are a mess and definitely need a cleanup. The set of 4 patches as a whole don't actually fix anything because for example, there's PCIe fixes in there, but given there hasn't been work done to add support for the PCIe IP that's in the bcm2712 SoC if they do fix something to make that work without the enablement patches they're basically a no-op. Also it seems you have an issue with your mail service because I never got [1] your mail about not applying something. What I would like to see, which I believe I asked for when the original series was sent, it is broken down into a few series: 1) Fixes for existing support without feature enablement 2) A PCIe enablement series, this would include, if necessary, and PCIe fixes like from this series, enable NVME etc 3) A patch series for the RP1 chip, the support here is now upstream so we know what this looks like, this would include any fixes for say macb so it can work, any config updates to enabled ethernet/USB etc. If you've got any clarifications feel free to either post here or happy to have a chat separately via IRC/matrix/VC etc. Cheers, Peter [1] https://lore.kernel.org/u-boot/[email protected]/
