Hi Christian,

you say : "I wonder how much the use case where the user filters the results, 
leaving the Dash home after having input the search query, should be 
prioritized."
well, to me this means: "lenses are useless". 

currently the only _truly_ lens-related feature is the "available in the
store" list  (which is present in the applications and music lenses
only).  this can be an interesting feature in terms of "discoverability"
and "upselling", but does it add that much value to the search?

now consider my concept.
the idea of a home lens which displays only recent content is more in the 
spirit of "a place where you can quickly search things that you know already 
you can easily access".  

this said, your comment points out what i consider to be a significant
bug in the dash: the lack of search persistence across the lenses. when
you hit the super key and then start typing, if you hit tab or click an
icon to switch to another lens, the search box turns empty.

i guess  this behaviour was implemented to let the user perform multiple
searches in different lenses, but, based on my experience, this scenario
is higly unlikely. as a user i expect the lenes to behave as filters and
not as "tabs".

you might argue that once you know about this behaviour, you will want to pick 
the appropriate lens before typing. 
but forcing the user to do so is clearly an "affordance" issue: if the first 
thing i see is a search box, i expect this search box to be the "leading" 
feature. i would never expect that something placed at the very bottom of the 
dash actually controls the behaviour of something that is placed at its top.

enabling search persistence across lenses could solve this issue, like
in the following use case:

user hits super key -> dash opens -> user types "ink" -> user notices no
results in "recent apps" (eg. recent = last 10 days) ->user hits tab to
switch to the applications lens -> user sees inkscape icon -> user hits
enter to launch inkscape


ps. sorry for the *long* post :)

-- 
You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu
Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu.
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/924923

Title:
  Lenses icons should be next to the search field (at least the default
  ones!)

To manage notifications about this bug go to:
https://bugs.launchpad.net/ayatana-design/+bug/924923/+subscriptions

-- 
ubuntu-bugs mailing list
ubuntu-bugs@lists.ubuntu.com
https://lists.ubuntu.com/mailman/listinfo/ubuntu-bugs

Reply via email to