I installed Ubuntu 14.10. After about 5 minutes of browsing the web, I
noticed the garbled graphics. This proved that the situation with the
integrated Intel x4500 graphics has worsened. As I was aware of what
caused the issue in 14.04, I disabled the swap partition by adding
“swapoff -a” to the “/etc/rc.local”  configuration file. I rebooted, and
tried the process again. It worked for a while but as the RAM began to
deplete I was still faced with the same issue of garbled graphics.

I went back to the “/etc/rc.local” configuration file and removed the
“swapoff -a” option. I remembered in 14.04 that editing the
“/etc/default/grub” configuration file to reserve RAM for the graphics
card helped tremendously while I was on 14.04. As I stated previously,
the Intel x4500 graphics chip is said to steal up to 384 MB of the
systems RAM (Source: http://www.notebookcheck.net/Intel-Graphics-Media-
Accelerator-4500MHD-GMA-X4500MHD.9883.0.html). Before I had alloted this
amount, which did help a great amount. However, occasionally when the
RAM began to deplete and the SWAP was used, I was still faced with the
issue of garbled graphics.

I decided to ignore the spec sheets written for the mobile x4500
graphics chip and went with the one present in the desktop version
(http://www.asus.com/Motherboards/P5G41CM_LX/specifications/). I edited
the grub configuration file to reserve 1GB of RAM (See comment #4 for
more details on how to configure GRUB). This RAM would be invisible to
Ubuntu while running and thus would not be disturbed when memory
available to the OS becomes depleted. For my test, I ran the computer
for over 3 hours, opened many Firefox tabs, visited many content rich
websites; websites that I know would eat RAM. I watched as the RAM
depleted. The computer gradually became slower, and processor usage
increased as expected. The SWAP usage was increasing, I continued, as I
maxed out the RAM, the SWAP usage increased but NO GARBLED GRAPHICS. I
randomly opened other applications, like Ardour 3 with a 50+ track
session, Hydrogen Drum Machine, LibreOffice writer, Thunderbird. I
continued until the the SWAP was almost maxed out and the computer
became unbearable to use.

Finally, I closed Firefox. This process would, under normal
circumstances instantly cause the entire screen to become garbled, as
the OS begins to flush the RAM and SWAP cache, restoring persistent
files temporarily stored in the SWAP back to the RAM. I watched the
System Monitor as the RAM and SWAP cache was restored. I viewed the dash
(an area that always became corrupt graphically). There was no
corruption anywhere. The speed of the computer was returned once the the
RAM was restored. In the past, with garbled graphics, the computer would
become unbearable to use, you would not be able to log out, you would
have to shut down. All functions were intact.

In conclusion and partly supporting my previous comments above. This is
not so much an issue with Swapping as it is an issue with what is being
Swapped. Before reserving that 1GB of RAM, Ubuntu would use all memory
available to the system as RAM depleted, before using the SWAP partition
(editing the SWAPiness has little to no effect on this). I did notice
some improvements in memory/SWAP management in Ubuntu 14.10 but the
issues with garbled graphics increased. This has led me to believe that
Ubuntu is Swapping the graphics data stored in RAM, this in turn causes
the garbled graphics.

By reserving 1GB of RAM (hidden from Ubuntu), The graphics chip always
has dedicated RAM available to it, even when the OS is supposedly
running out of RAM and starts Swapping. By reserving that RAM, it is
always available to the graphics chip, all graphics data stays in that
dedicated RAM and does not get Swapped, hence no more garbled graphics.
It is my theory that in order to solve the issue with garbled graphics
on the Intel x4500, we would have to instruct Ubuntu to keep all
graphics data in RAM and never SWAP it. SWAP only application data.
Until this fix is implemented, this workaround is the best option you
have got.

-- 
You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu
Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu.
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1358936

Title:
  [gm45] L-shaped memory with invalid swizzling

To manage notifications about this bug go to:
https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/xserver-xorg-video-intel/+bug/1358936/+subscriptions

-- 
ubuntu-bugs mailing list
ubuntu-bugs@lists.ubuntu.com
https://lists.ubuntu.com/mailman/listinfo/ubuntu-bugs

Reply via email to