Perhaps I'm too late on this, but powernap is exactly the application
that I'm looking for.  I am running a headless Ubuntu home server as a
NAS and web server.  The server is typically only being accessed 1-2
hours a day so I would prefer that it go into a lower power state when
not being used.  My current solution is a PowerShell script on my
Windows computer that lets me (and my non-techy wife) completely shut
down the server remotely.  I have wake on LAN set up to bring it back up
remotely.  I tried having the server automatically suspend, but it seems
that only keyboard/mouse input will reset the suspend timer, so it will
always suspend after the set time regardless of whether it is being used
or not.  Powernap was exactly the application I needed to check if there
is any traffic on Apache, Samba, or MySQL before suspending (and reset
the countdown if there is).

I tried looking at the proposed alternative solution using OpenStack
Watcher.  I have some basic Linux skills, but am still mostly a
beginner.  I spent about 10 hours trying to set watcher up and have yet
to get it working in even the most basic sense.  The tutorial presumes I
already have full knowledge of OpenStack and MySQL (I have some MySQL
experience and no OpenStack experience), so most answers require
significant sub-research (and often sub-sub-research, etc).  A good
portion of that time was also spent trying to install powernap manually
using the downloaded package.  Nearly every tutorial I saw online for
installing packages involves the "make" command, but that doesn't seem
to be an option for powernap (no "makefile" apparently).

For what it's worth, it seems from my internet searching that my use
case (small headless server that doesn't need to be up all the time) is
the use case for the large majority of powernap users.  I understand
that this isn't being maintained anymore, and if the decision is that it
should stay removed for that reason despite it's current use cases an
relevancy, I understand that.  I just wanted to make sure it's
understood that it absolutely still has a valuable use case today.

-- 
You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu
Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu.
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1853001

Title:
  RM powernap binary & source packages from Focal

To manage notifications about this bug go to:
https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/powernap/+bug/1853001/+subscriptions

-- 
ubuntu-bugs mailing list
ubuntu-bugs@lists.ubuntu.com
https://lists.ubuntu.com/mailman/listinfo/ubuntu-bugs

Reply via email to