Conrad Knauer wrote: > What is there to stop Dell from including all sorts of non-free codecs > and STILL calling it Ubuntu? At what point does Ubuntu slide down the > slippery slope and the "Ubuntu promise" become a bad joke? > The Ubuntu promise has always been that *we* will publish a system which has only free software applications, but that we would work with proprietary vendors to make sure their stuff works on Ubuntu because Ubuntu users have every right to choose a proprietary application if they want. We took the difficult step of deciding to include proprietary drivers precisely because we WANT people to experience free software, even if their hardware provider has not yet figured out how to do Linux properly. In this case Dell is the user, and Dell is also acting on behalf of their customers.
The underlying idea is that Ubuntu should express the best of free software, but that it should also be useful to EVERYONE and a platform on top of which people can build even if they don't have entirely the same set of values. We are not trying to beat freedom into the skulls of those who do not want it, we are showing them what is possible and leading them towards that freedom one step at a time. The set of people who will build their own kernel with all the firmware removed is very, very small, and they can help themselves. We, at ubuntu.com, aim to reach a wider audience, which is people who are passionate about free software and want a trusted, convenient place to get it. They will make their own decisions about non-free applications they might add, just as you describe. Dell is aiming for a slightly wider audience, of people who are willing to try something more advanced or new, but don't want to stumble on something they consider a basic element, such as DVD playback, just because there are US patents on that technology. -- Microsoft has a majority market share https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1 You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is the bug contact for Ubuntu. -- ubuntu-bugs mailing list ubuntu-bugs@lists.ubuntu.com https://lists.ubuntu.com/mailman/listinfo/ubuntu-bugs
