** Attachment added: "gkbd-azerty-light.png"
https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/gnome-shell/+bug/2068243/+attachment/5786335/+files/gkbd-azerty-light.png
** Description changed:
Impact
======
GNOME 45 switched their default keyboard layout viewer from libgnomekbd to
tecla. This change was made in gnome-control-center but Debian and Ubuntu
carried a patch to revert this for gnome-shell because gnome-shell wasn't
calling tecla correctly which made the keyboard layout viewer not work
correctly for some keyboard layouts.
The gnome-shell bug was fixed in 46.2.
Tecla has these advantages compared to libgnomekbd:
- Uses GTK4 and libadwaita
- - Which means support for the dark style preference
- - Much more modern looking window dialog
+ - Which means improved support for the dark style preference (Ubuntu enables
dark style in many more places than GNOME normally does so the libgnomekbd
viewer has partial dark style support in Ubuntu.)
+ - Much more modern looking window
- Consistency with the existing ⋮ > View Keyboard Layout in GNOME Settings >
Keyboard
- Does what every other GNOME 45 or GNOME 46 distro does
Therefore, this SRU drops the revert patch, drops Recommends: gkbd-
capplet and adds Depends: tecla. apt should mark gkbd-capplet for
autoremoval since nothing in the default Ubuntu Desktop Depends or
Recommends it any more. It is harmless if either gkbd-capplet is
uninstalled or kept installed.
gnome-control-center already has Depends: tecla so this is not
installing anything new.
Test Case
=========
From a terminal, run sudo apt install language-pack-gnome-fr
Install the gnome-shell update. Log out and log back in.
Open the GNOME Settings app (gnome-control-center).
In the left sidebar, click Keyboard.
Click Add Input Source…
In the dialog, choose French (France), then choose French (AZERTY) then Add.
In the right side of GNOME Shell's top bar, the keyboard layout switcher
should be visible with en. Click en then change the keyboard layout to French
(AZERTY).
Click Show Keyboard Layout.
A popup should show a keyboard layout with the second row of characters
beginning with a z e r t y as shown in the tecla-azerty-light.png or
tecla-azerty-dark.png screenshots.
Close the keyboard layout popup.
Switch the keyboard layout back to en
Click Show Keyboard Layout
The popup should display with the keyboard layout set to your usual English
keyboard layout.
What Could Go Wrong
===================
This is a fairly minor feature and should not be essential to anyone who
needs alternate keyboard layouts. I would guess people would be more likely to
click the ⋮ > View Keyboard Layout option in GNOME Settings > Keyboard when
choosing input sources rather than via GNOME Shell. And GNOME Settings was
already set to use Tecla.
This change does not affect actual usability of alternate keyboard
layouts, just the single button to view the layout.
Other Info
==========
This change means that libgnomekbd will be demoted from main to universe for
Ubuntu 24.10. For technical reasons, that demotion is not possible for already
released stable versions of Ubuntu like Ubuntu 24.04 LTS.
** Also affects: gnome-shell (Ubuntu Noble)
Importance: Undecided
Status: New
** Changed in: gnome-shell (Ubuntu Noble)
Status: New => Triaged
** Changed in: gnome-shell (Ubuntu Noble)
Importance: Undecided => Low
** Description changed:
Impact
======
GNOME 45 switched their default keyboard layout viewer from libgnomekbd to
tecla. This change was made in gnome-control-center but Debian and Ubuntu
carried a patch to revert this for gnome-shell because gnome-shell wasn't
calling tecla correctly which made the keyboard layout viewer not work
correctly for some keyboard layouts.
The gnome-shell bug was fixed in 46.2.
Tecla has these advantages compared to libgnomekbd:
- Uses GTK4 and libadwaita
- Which means improved support for the dark style preference (Ubuntu enables
dark style in many more places than GNOME normally does so the libgnomekbd
viewer has partial dark style support in Ubuntu.)
- Much more modern looking window
- Consistency with the existing ⋮ > View Keyboard Layout in GNOME Settings >
Keyboard
- Does what every other GNOME 45 or GNOME 46 distro does
+ (Screenshots attached to show differences)
Therefore, this SRU drops the revert patch, drops Recommends: gkbd-
capplet and adds Depends: tecla. apt should mark gkbd-capplet for
autoremoval since nothing in the default Ubuntu Desktop Depends or
Recommends it any more. It is harmless if either gkbd-capplet is
uninstalled or kept installed.
gnome-control-center already has Depends: tecla so this is not
installing anything new.
Test Case
=========
From a terminal, run sudo apt install language-pack-gnome-fr
Install the gnome-shell update. Log out and log back in.
Open the GNOME Settings app (gnome-control-center).
In the left sidebar, click Keyboard.
Click Add Input Source…
In the dialog, choose French (France), then choose French (AZERTY) then Add.
In the right side of GNOME Shell's top bar, the keyboard layout switcher
should be visible with en. Click en then change the keyboard layout to French
(AZERTY).
Click Show Keyboard Layout.
A popup should show a keyboard layout with the second row of characters
beginning with a z e r t y as shown in the tecla-azerty-light.png or
tecla-azerty-dark.png screenshots.
Close the keyboard layout popup.
Switch the keyboard layout back to en
Click Show Keyboard Layout
The popup should display with the keyboard layout set to your usual English
keyboard layout.
What Could Go Wrong
===================
This is a fairly minor feature and should not be essential to anyone who
needs alternate keyboard layouts. I would guess people would be more likely to
click the ⋮ > View Keyboard Layout option in GNOME Settings > Keyboard when
choosing input sources rather than via GNOME Shell. And GNOME Settings was
already set to use Tecla.
This change does not affect actual usability of alternate keyboard
layouts, just the single button to view the layout.
Other Info
==========
This change means that libgnomekbd will be demoted from main to universe for
Ubuntu 24.10. For technical reasons, that demotion is not possible for already
released stable versions of Ubuntu like Ubuntu 24.04 LTS.
--
You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu
Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu.
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/2068243
Title:
Switch keyboard layout viewer to tecla
To manage notifications about this bug go to:
https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/gnome-shell/+bug/2068243/+subscriptions
--
ubuntu-bugs mailing list
ubuntu-bugs@lists.ubuntu.com
https://lists.ubuntu.com/mailman/listinfo/ubuntu-bugs
