Hi Renan, thank you so much for the feedback! Please consider my answers below for clarity, I'll duplicate them in the bug as well for completeness.
1. The license for the entire package is GPLv3, apologies I missed it in the original bug. Since the package is just configuration files created by me I think GPLv3 is the most suitable. 2/3. Thank you for the explanation about the nativity of the package! I really appreciate that. This software hardly makes sense outside of Ubuntu, because it's a part of the Renesas<>Ubuntu engagement[1], for example adding the `drp-ai` groups allows us to use the DRP-AI devices on the Renesas EVKs, they are only integrated into the Ubuntu images we issue and nowhere else, same with codec rules. I don't think this package should go through Debian because of this reason. Regarding the upstream project I will create it. I just realized no one is able to see the source code of the package due to project being private. I used git-buildpackage, but I can switch to git-ubuntu, no problems. 4. This package does not need urgent inclusion, thank you for the feedback, I'll keep it in mind for packages that come next. Many thanks for the review! I'll fix the issues and get back to you. [1]: https://ubuntu.com/download/renesas-iot ** Description changed: [overview] renesas-iot-defaults is a collection of configuration files that help users of Renesas RZ evaluation kits (https://www.renesas.com/en/products/microcontrollers-microprocessors/rz-mpus#overview). [contents] - /etc/default/grub.d/99-renesas-iot-defaults.cfg The only function of this file is to remove `quiet` from kernel cmd line to make development and debugging of this experimental devices easier. - /usr/lib/systemd/system/fwupd-refresh.timer.d/50-renesas-iot-defaults.conf During HW QA test runs, we realize that fwupd-refresh.service failed in reboot cycle intermittenly. The root cause likely lies with RZ/G2L (DUT) being 1.2GHz CPU / 1GB RAM power-efficient board and restricting system resources during the boot storm. The fix is this file, that makes fwupd avoid the boot storm without affecting the actual boot time. - /usr/lib/udev/rules.d/50-rz-codec.rules - /usr/lib/udev/rules.d/60-rz-drpai.rules Udev rules that allow a non-priviledged user to access codec and AI-related devices in /dev. - /usr/share/metainfo/com.canonical.renesas-iot-defaults.metainfo.xml A metainfo file that comes with the above mentioned udev rules. [testing] HW IoT QAs have tested pre-built images that include equivalent package from a private PPA (https://launchpad.net/~koto-team/+archive/ubuntu/koto-proposed). I also tested it on noble and resolute (installing/removing) manually from the test ppa(see next). I have not yet tested it on stonking due to the image being not yet released for this particular line of devices. I don't think a couple of configuration files may cause a major bug, but I'm greatly appreciating about any testing strategy for stonking that you might suggest. My main goal is to upload for stonking and then SRU to noble and resolute (currently supported series by RZ line of devices). [versioning] I would like to request the version of the package starts from 1.2 (not from 1.0) due to existing published images containing a package of the same name up to version 1.1 (from a private PPA). For the same reason I would like to request the preservation of the existing changelog. [source & test ppa] - Source code for various Ubuntu series: + Source code for various Ubuntu series for reference: noble: https://code.launchpad.net/~asaly12/+git/renesas-iot-defaults/+ref/ubuntu/noble resolute: https://code.launchpad.net/~asaly12/+git/renesas-iot-defaults/+ref/ubuntu/resolute stonking: https://code.launchpad.net/~asaly12/+git/renesas-iot-defaults/+ref/ubuntu/stonking + I will create a project for Renesas shortly and move the repository + there. + The upstream for this package is the `files` folder in the same - repository as the `debian` folder, which makes this a native Ubuntu - package. + repository as the `debian` folder. + + This software hardly makes sense outside of Ubuntu, because it's a part of the Renesas<>Ubuntu engagement[1], for example adding the `drp-ai` groups allows us to use the DRP-AI devices on the Renesas EVKs, they are only integrated into the Ubuntu images we issue and nowhere else, same with codec rules. + I don't think this package should go through Debian because of this reason. If anyone wants to give it a go, check out this PPA: https://launchpad.net/~asaly12/+archive/ubuntu/renesas-iot-defaults-test/+packages Published pre-built image that include an equivalent package: https://ubuntu.com/download/renesas-iot [conclusion] This package contains many useful configuration files for Renesas RZ users, I wish to package it into the main archive to make sure anyone can make use of it. + + [1]: https://ubuntu.com/download/renesas-iot -- You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu. https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/2151177 Title: [needs packaging] renesas-iot-defaults To manage notifications about this bug go to: https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+bug/2151177/+subscriptions -- ubuntu-bugs mailing list [email protected] https://lists.ubuntu.com/mailman/listinfo/ubuntu-bugs
