** Description changed: [ Impact ] - * On the MediaTek MT8391-EVK (Genio 720/520 EVK), the alsa-ucm-conf - profile has three problems: + * On the MediaTek MT8391-EVK (Genio 720/520 EVK), the alsa-ucm-conf + profile has three problems: - - The Speaker device has only 1 channel, so the earphone output is - mono (center only). + - The Speaker device has only 1 channel, so the earphone output is + mono (center only). - - There are no hardware volume controls for Speaker, Headphones, - Headset and Mic1. The volume sliders do not change the hardware - gain and recordings from the analog microphone are very quiet. + - There are no hardware volume controls for Speaker, Headphones, + Headset and Mic1. The volume sliders do not change the hardware + gain and recordings from the analog microphone are very quiet. - - There is no device for the DisplayPort output on the USB-C port, - so no audio sink appears for an external monitor. + - There is no device for the DisplayPort output on the USB-C port, + so no audio sink appears for an external monitor. - * Upstream fixed the first two problems in 8275e1b and added the - DisplayPort output in 8048d93. Both commits are merged upstream but - are not in any release yet. + * Upstream fixed the first two problems in 8275e1b and added the + DisplayPort output in 8048d93. Both commits are merged upstream but + are not in any release yet. - * 8048d93 sets DPTX_OUT_MUX and HDMI_CH1_MUX only in the BootSequence, - which runs from "alsactl init". On a normal boot alsa-restore replays - the saved ALSA state instead. After an upgrade and a reboot: + * 8048d93 sets DPTX_OUT_MUX and HDMI_CH1_MUX only in the BootSequence, + which runs from "alsactl init". On a normal boot alsa-restore replays + the saved ALSA state instead. After an upgrade and a reboot: - - A saved DPTX_OUT_MUX=Disconnect makes the DisplayPort PCM - (hw:CardId,5) fail to open. WirePlumber then drops the whole HiFi - profile and only a dummy output and no inputs are left. + - A saved DPTX_OUT_MUX=Disconnect makes the DisplayPort PCM + (hw:CardId,5) fail to open. WirePlumber then drops the whole HiFi + profile and only a dummy output and no inputs are left. - - A saved HDMI_CH1_MUX=CH0 leaves the right DisplayPort channel - silent. + - A saved HDMI_CH1_MUX=CH0 leaves the right DisplayPort channel + silent. - * A third patch, the fix for 8048d93, sets the three DisplayPort muxes - from the HiFi verb EnableSequence, so they are applied every time - the profile is activated. 8048d93 must not be shipped without it. + * A third patch, the fix for 8048d93, sets the three DisplayPort muxes + from the HiFi verb EnableSequence, so they are applied every time + the profile is activated. 8048d93 must not be shipped without it. [ Test Plan ] - * Hardware used for the SRU verification: - - MediaTek Genio 720 EVK (MT8391-EVK) with display-dpoc.dtbo in - list_dtbo, and a DisplayPort monitor with speakers on the USB-C - DP port (directly or through a USB-C hub). - - Framework Laptop 13 (AMD Ryzen AI 300 Series), x86_64, for the - regression test on non-MT8391 hardware. + * Hardware used for the SRU verification: + - MediaTek Genio 720 EVK (MT8391-EVK) with display-dpoc.dtbo in + list_dtbo, and a DisplayPort monitor with speakers on the USB-C + DP port (directly or through a USB-C hub). + - Framework Laptop 13 (AMD Ryzen AI 300 Series), x86_64, for the + regression test on non-MT8391 hardware. - * Images on the Genio 720 EVK: - - Noble: the official Ubuntu 24.04 desktop image for Genio. - - Resolute and Stonking: there is no official Genio image for these - releases. A special arm64 image is prepared for the SRU - verification only, as was done for Questing in LP: #2139651. + * Images on the Genio 720 EVK: + - Noble: the official Ubuntu 24.04 desktop image for Genio. + - Resolute and Stonking: there is no official Genio image for these + releases. A special arm64 image is prepared for the SRU + verification only, as was done for Questing in LP: #2139651. - * The same steps are run on Noble, Resolute and Stonking, with the - package from -proposed installed. Results are posted as one comment - per release, with the installed version from - "apt-cache policy alsa-ucm-conf" and the command output. + * The same steps are run on Noble, Resolute and Stonking, with the + package from -proposed installed. Results are posted as one comment + per release, with the installed version from + "apt-cache policy alsa-ucm-conf" and the command output. - 1. Enable -proposed, install the updated alsa-ucm-conf, reboot and log - in to the desktop. + 1. Enable -proposed, install the updated alsa-ucm-conf, reboot and log + in to the desktop. - 2. Run: wpctl status - Confirm these sinks: "DP output", "I2S output", "PCM output", - "Earphone speaker + Lineout speaker". - Confirm these sources: "I2S input", "PCM input", - "Digital microphone", "Analog microphone + Earphone microphone". + 2. Run: wpctl status + Confirm these sinks: "DP output", "I2S output", "PCM output", + "Earphone speaker + Lineout speaker". + Confirm these sources: "I2S input", "PCM input", + "Digital microphone", "Analog microphone + Earphone microphone". - 3. Stale state after a reboot: - sudo amixer -c0 cset name=DPTX_OUT_MUX Disconnect - sudo amixer -c0 cset name=HDMI_CH1_MUX CH0 - sudo alsactl store - Reboot and log in. Confirm that the sinks and sources are the same - as in step 2, that - sudo amixer -c0 cget name=DPTX_OUT_MUX - shows Connect, that - sudo amixer -c0 cget name=HDMI_CH1_MUX - shows CH1, and that - journalctl --user -b -u wireplumber - has no "Error opening PCM device" line. + 3. Stale state after a reboot: + sudo amixer -c0 cset name=DPTX_OUT_MUX Disconnect + sudo amixer -c0 cset name=HDMI_CH1_MUX CH0 + sudo alsactl store + Reboot and log in. Confirm that the sinks and sources are the same + as in step 2, that + sudo amixer -c0 cget name=DPTX_OUT_MUX + shows Connect, that + sudo amixer -c0 cget name=HDMI_CH1_MUX + shows CH1, and that + journalctl --user -b -u wireplumber + has no "Error opening PCM device" line. - 4. Select "DP output" in Settings > Sound and run the speaker test. - Confirm that Front Left and Front Right are heard from the monitor. + 4. Select "DP output" in Settings > Sound and run the speaker test. + Confirm that Front Left and Front Right are heard from the monitor. - 5. Plug in headphones, select them and run the speaker test. Confirm - that left and right are heard on the matching side and not in the - center. + 5. Plug in headphones, select them and run the speaker test. Confirm + that left and right are heard on the matching side and not in the + center. - 6. Move the output and input volume sliders. Confirm that - "Headset Volume", "Lineout Volume" and "PGA1 Volume" follow them in - alsamixer, and that a recording from the analog microphone has a - usable level. + 6. Move the output and input volume sliders. Confirm that + "Headset Volume", "Lineout Volume" and "PGA1 Volume" follow them in + alsamixer, and that a recording from the analog microphone has a + usable level. - 7. Boot with the default overlays (no display-dpoc.dtbo). Confirm that - there is no DP output and that all other sinks and sources from - step 2 are present. + 7. Boot with the default overlays (no display-dpoc.dtbo). Confirm that + there is no DP output and that all other sinks and sources from + step 2 are present. - 8. Regression test on the Framework Laptop 13: install the update, - play and record audio with the built-in speakers and microphone, - and confirm that "journalctl -b" has no new UCM errors. + 8. Regression test on the Framework Laptop 13: install the update, + play and record audio with the built-in speakers and microphone, + and confirm that "journalctl -b" has no new UCM errors. - * Tenacious (the development release) is a normal upload and is not - part of the SRU verification. + * Tenacious (the development release) is a normal upload and is not + part of the SRU verification. [ Where problems could occur ] - * Only files under ucm2/MediaTek/mt8391-evk/ change. They are loaded - only for the mt8391-evk sound card, so other hardware is not - affected. To verify this, examine each debdiff attached to this bug: - the three patches touch only ucm2/MediaTek/mt8391-evk/HiFi.conf. + * Only files under ucm2/MediaTek/mt8391-evk/ change. They are loaded + only for the mt8391-evk sound card, so other hardware is not + affected. To verify this, examine each debdiff attached to this bug: + the three patches touch only ucm2/MediaTek/mt8391-evk/HiFi.conf. - * On the MT8391-EVK: + * On the MT8391-EVK: - - The verb EnableSequence runs every time the profile is activated. - If a kernel or device tree does not register one of the three mux - controls, activating the profile could fail and audio would be - lost. Test Plan step 7 covers the default overlays. + - The verb EnableSequence runs every time the profile is activated. + If a kernel or device tree does not register one of the three mux + controls, activating the profile could fail and audio would be + lost. Test Plan step 7 covers the default overlays. - - Speaker and Headphones priorities move to 400 and 500, above the - DP output (300). With a monitor attached the default output stays - the speaker and the user selects DP in the settings. + - Speaker and Headphones priorities move to 400 and 500, above the + DP output (300). With a monitor attached the default output stays + the speaker and the user selects DP in the settings. - - The volume sliders now drive the hardware gain, so the default - microphone level differs from before (louder). + - The volume sliders now drive the hardware gain, so the default + microphone level differs from before (louder). [ Other Info ] - * Upstream status: + * Upstream status: - - Patches 1 and 2 are backports of upstream commits merged on - master. The latest release, v1.2.16.1, does not contain them yet. - 1. 8275e1b6577b "ucm2: MediaTek: mt8391-evk: Fix channels and add - volume controls" - https://github.com/alsa-project/alsa-ucm-conf/commit/8275e1b6577b - 2. 8048d93df191 "ucm2: MediaTek: mt8391-evk: Add DisplayPort output - audio support" - https://github.com/alsa-project/alsa-ucm-conf/commit/8048d93df191 - - Patch 3 is the fix for patch 2 and is NOT YET MERGED upstream: - 3. "ucm2: MediaTek: mt8391-evk: Set the DP audio muxes in the verb" - (Fixes: 8048d93) - https://github.com/alsa-project/alsa-ucm-conf/pull/902 - This bug will be updated when it merges, and the DEP-3 Origin of - patch 3 will be changed to the upstream commit. + - Patches 1 and 2 are backports of upstream commits merged on + master. The latest release, v1.2.16.1, does not contain them yet. + 1. 8275e1b6577b "ucm2: MediaTek: mt8391-evk: Fix channels and add + volume controls" + https://github.com/alsa-project/alsa-ucm-conf/commit/8275e1b6577b + 2. 8048d93df191 "ucm2: MediaTek: mt8391-evk: Add DisplayPort output + audio support" + https://github.com/alsa-project/alsa-ucm-conf/commit/8048d93df191 + - Patch 3 is the fix for patch 2 and is NOT YET MERGED upstream: + 3. "ucm2: MediaTek: mt8391-evk: Set the DP audio muxes in the verb" + (Fixes: 8048d93) + https://github.com/alsa-project/alsa-ucm-conf/pull/902 + This bug will be updated when it merges, and the DEP-3 Origin of + patch 3 will be changed to the upstream commit. - * Sponsorship is requested. Debdiffs for Tenacious, Stonking, Resolute - and Noble will be attached to this bug. Each series gets the same - three patches, named after this bug number: - - lp<bug>-ucm2-MediaTek-mt8391-evk-Fix-channels-and-add-volume-controls.patch - - lp<bug>-ucm2-MediaTek-mt8391-evk-Add-DisplayPort-output-audio-support.patch - - lp<bug>-ucm2-MediaTek-mt8391-evk-Set-the-DP-audio-muxes-in-the-verb.patch - The resulting ucm2/MediaTek/mt8391-evk files are identical in all - four series. + * Sponsorship is requested. Debdiffs for Tenacious, Stonking, Resolute + and Noble will be attached to this bug. Each series gets the same + three patches, named after this bug number: + - lp2173715-ucm2-MediaTek-mt8391-evk-Fix-channels-and-add-volume-controls.patch + - lp2173715-ucm2-MediaTek-mt8391-evk-Add-DisplayPort-output-audio-support.patch + - lp2173715-ucm2-MediaTek-mt8391-evk-Set-the-DP-audio-muxes-in-the-verb.patch + The resulting ucm2/MediaTek/mt8391-evk files are identical in all + four series. - * Debian: the first two patches are upstream commits and reach Debian - with the next upstream release. Patch 3 is forwarded - upstream as PR #902. No separate Debian bug is planned. + * Debian: the first two patches are upstream commits and reach Debian + with the next upstream release. Patch 3 is forwarded + upstream as PR #902. No separate Debian bug is planned. - * Tested on a Genio 720 EVK running 24.04: stereo output and volume - controls, and DisplayPort audio including a reboot with a stale - saved state, with the same changes except the Speaker and - Headphones priority values. + * Tested on a Genio 720 EVK running 24.04: stereo output and volume + controls, and DisplayPort audio including a reboot with a stale + saved state, with the same changes except the Speaker and + Headphones priority values. - * Target releases: - - Tenacious: 1.2.16.1-1ubuntu1 -> 1.2.16.1-1ubuntu2 - - Stonking: 1.2.16.1-1ubuntu1 -> 1.2.16.1-1ubuntu1.1 - - Resolute: 1.2.15.3-1ubuntu1.7 -> 1.2.15.3-1ubuntu1.8 - - Noble: 1.2.10-1ubuntu5.16 -> 1.2.10-1ubuntu5.17 - (5.16 is in noble-proposed, LP: #2068911) + * Target releases: + - Tenacious: 1.2.16.1-1ubuntu1 -> 1.2.16.1-1ubuntu2 + - Stonking: 1.2.16.1-1ubuntu1 -> 1.2.16.1-1ubuntu1.1 + - Resolute: 1.2.15.3-1ubuntu1.7 -> 1.2.15.3-1ubuntu1.8 + - Noble: 1.2.10-1ubuntu5.16 -> 1.2.10-1ubuntu5.17 + (5.16 is in noble-proposed, LP: #2068911) - * The Tenacious and Stonking debdiffs also run update-maintainer, - because the current upload still has the Debian maintainer in - debian/control. + * The Tenacious and Stonking debdiffs also run update-maintainer, + because the current upload still has the Debian maintainer in + debian/control.
-- You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu. https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/2173715 Title: [SRU] MediaTek MT8391-EVK: fix stereo output, add volume controls and DisplayPort audio To manage notifications about this bug go to: https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/alsa-ucm-conf/+bug/2173715/+subscriptions -- ubuntu-bugs mailing list [email protected] https://lists.ubuntu.com/mailman/listinfo/ubuntu-bugs
