Thanks for reporting; assigning to ubuntu-gdm-themes and subscribing
Kenneth.

I agree that the changes are a big step back. The following quote is
from last week's desktop team meeting minutes:

> * GDM: made new entry box svg with an offset box rather than an inset
>  version, tweaked the bg to be "lighter" and "friendlier" and changed the logo
>  to have more "glow".

Here are the problems with the new design as I see them:

* The old design for the entry box could be perceived as being level
with the rest of the "surface" and was much more harmonious. The offset
box, along with the increased brightness, fights too much for attention.

* The new color balance looks completely washed out on an average LCD.
I'm not sure how the background being lighter is supposed to contribute
to a "friendlier" look; the old colors were much more saturated, were
more harmonious with the default wallpaper, yet were not so dark as to
need lightening in order not to look depressing.

* The white(ish) gradient at the bottom emphasizes the division of the
footer too much, suffers from banding, and makes the washed out
appearance even more noticeable.

I would strongly suggest reverting to the old version, especially given
that the beta has shipped with the old design (which I've seen many
people call the best of any Ubuntu release), and we're past the artwork
deadline.

-- 
Hardy: Ubuntu login screen art has brightnes increased
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/211740
You received this bug notification because you are a member of Ubuntu
Bugs, which is subscribed to Ubuntu.

-- 
ubuntu-bugs mailing list
ubuntu-bugs@lists.ubuntu.com
https://lists.ubuntu.com/mailman/listinfo/ubuntu-bugs

Reply via email to