John Clews wrote as follows. quote
In fairness, you ought to take account of the fact that languages of the Indian subcontinent have been displayed on TV systems in India for nearly ten years, based around ISCII. Is there a reason for doing anything different for DVB-MHP? Or are mappings and similar accounted for in your paper? end quote Many thanks for your note. The whole text of my document is in the posting. I know very little about Indian languages. It is just that I know that DVB-MHP uses Java and Unicode and that the built-in font for the minimum DVB-MHP television set is very European languages oriented. Please see Annex E of the DVB-MHP specification, available from the http://www.mhp.org webspace. I have suggested in another document in the DigitalTV forum in the http://www.cenelec.org webspace some additional characters which I feel would be good additions for the built-in font for the European Union interactive television. This is entirely in compliance with the DVB-MHP specification, as the specification provides many options for local implementation and specifies a minimum implementation. Within the European Union there will potentially be a "local implementation" though covering the whole of the European Union, so suggesting some extra characters to be in the built-in font of all such televisions is just part of the process of deciding which options to include in the local implementation for the European Union. I am simply trying to point out that using languages of the Indian subcontinent upon the DVB-MHP system with its PFR0 font system may cause problems, in the hope that experts will look at the problem soon as there at present seems to be little (or maybe no) intersection in the set of people who know about DVB-MHP and the set of people who know about languages of the Indian subcontinent expressed in Unicode. I am concerned that if nothing is done there will be problems in a few years time with lots of interoperability problems, whereas looking at the problem now could save a lot of problems later. The possibilities for using the DVB-MHP system for education around the world are enormous. The Indian subcontinent is one major potential area of such use. I am concerned to try to ensure that there is a good infrastructure in place so that the languages of the Indian subcontinent may be used in a Unicode manner upon the DVB-MHP platform in a straightforward manner. On the specific matters which you mention, I had no knowledge of the fact that languages of the Indian subcontinent have been displayed on TV systems in India for nearly ten years, based around ISCII. That is interesting to know. Is that on a teletext system or what? However, as far as I know ISCII is an 8-bit encoding system (and I do mean "as far as I know" because I am not certain of that) whereas DVB-MHP uses Unicode. So not including mention of ISCII in my document is no problem as far as I know. Mappings from ISCII to Unicode are not mentioned in my document. I started from considering that someone had encoded some text written in a language of the Indian subcontinent into Unicode and that it was in a text file ready for broadcasting and considered the process of getting the text displayed upon the screen of a DVB-MHP television. I then pointed out what, to me, seems a problem which presently exists, in that a PFR0 font, as far as I can tell, is not a smart font format. I am hoping that, by having published the paper in the DigitalTV forum in the http://www.cenelec.org webspace that the matter may be resolved within the context of the setting of content authoring guidelines for interactive television which are to be produced for the European Union. Certainly, I cannot resolve the matter myself as I do not have the linguistic knowledge necessary to do so. I suggest using glyphs mapped to the Private Use Area from U+EC00 for this specific application of Unicode upon the DVB-MHP platform, though not broadcasting using those code points in relation to languages of the Indian subcontinent, just using them locally for font access after they are generated using a eutocode typography file. I have since been wondering what is the position of displaying Arabic text using a PFR0 font upon the DVB-MHP platform. Does a similar problem exist? Would the set of Arabic presentation forms encoded into Unicode be sufficient for the task, so that a Private Use Area encoding would not be necessary? The right to left display of Arabic text is another factor which needs consideration in relation to the DVB-MHP system. Thank you for your interest. William Overington 3 April 2003
