So do you think I should lodge this as a bug ?
On 20 May 2011 07:46, Sean Van Buggenum <sva...@gmail.com> wrote: > > I should confirm, I am running > > 1.0-milestone-3<http://repo.gradle.org/gradle/distributions/gradle-1.0-milestone-3-all.zip> > > And what I seem to have discovered, is a bug that was apparently already > fixed back in 2008? > > http://gradle.1045684.n5.nabble.com/Failing-Test-under-Windows-in-Stealth-Mode-td1436860.html > > > > On 19 May 2011 09:21, Sean Van Buggenum <sva...@gmail.com> wrote: > >> Hi Adam, >> >> I made a short test application to demonstrate it, and to ensure that it >> wasn't an issue particular to my complicated build script. >> The problem exists even in this simple script, and I paste the script, and >> both running of the script (first linux, then windows XP) to show. >> Please let me know if you get the same results. If not, and you'd like the >> more verbose logout (-debug or stacktrace option) please let me know. >> Obviously the point is, the two runs on linux result in different exit >> values because the first provides the required property, the second not. >> On windows, when the required propery is not provided, the script returns >> with exit value zero anyway (incorrectly, I believe). >> >> Sean >> >> p.s. Please note, the only difference in the scripts run on linux and >> windows, is that on linux, gradle is referred to as 'gradle', and on >> windows, as 'gradle.bat' (otherwise, it won't run). >> >> =================== >> script: build.gradle >> --------------------------------- >> >> task first << { >> println 'first!' >> >> def moduleBuildResult = exec { >> executable = 'gradle' >> args = ['second', >> "-Pmy_property="+"hello!!", >> ] >> ignoreExitValue = true >> } >> >> println "Exit value for second build is: " + >> moduleBuildResult.getExitValue() >> >> moduleBuildResult = exec { >> executable = 'gradle' >> args = ['second' >> ] >> ignoreExitValue = true >> } >> >> println "Exit value for second build is: " + >> moduleBuildResult.getExitValue() >> >> } >> >> >> task second << { >> println "second! ${my_property}" >> >> } >> >> ======================================================== >> >> log out for linux: >> -------------------- >> >> >> seanvb@svUbuntuX2:/mnt/data/dev2/bugtest$ gradle first >> :first >> first! >> :second >> second! hello!! >> >> BUILD SUCCESSFUL >> >> Total time: 3.372 secs >> Exit value for second build is: 0 >> :second >> >> FAILURE: Build failed with an exception. >> >> * Where: >> Build file '/mnt/data/dev2/bugtest/build.gradle' line: 30 >> >> * What went wrong: >> Execution failed for task ':second'. >> Cause: Could not find property 'my_property' on task ':second'. >> >> * Try: >> Run with --stacktrace option to get the stack trace. Run with --info or >> --debug option to get more log output. >> >> BUILD FAILED >> >> Total time: 3.246 secs >> Exit value for second build is: 1 >> >> BUILD SUCCESSFUL >> >> >> =========================================== >> >> log out for windows >> ---------------------------------------- >> >> >> D:\dev\scripts\testbug>gradle first >> :first >> first! >> :second >> second! hello!! >> >> BUILD SUCCESSFUL >> >> Total time: 2.543 secs >> Exit value for second build is: 0 >> :second >> FAILURE: Build failed with an exception. >> >> >> >> * Where: >> Build file 'D:\dev\scripts\testbug\build.gradle' line: 30 >> >> BUILD FAILED >> >> Total time: 2.474 secs >> * What went wrong: >> Execution failed for task ':second'. >> Cause: Could not find property 'my_property' on task ':second'. >> >> * Try: >> Run with --stacktrace option to get the stack trace. Run with --info or >> --debug option to get more log output. >> Exit value for second build is: 0 >> >> BUILD SUCCESSFUL >> >> Total time: 9.253 secs >> D:\dev\scripts\testbug> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >>> Does your log file contain anything useful? >>> >>> >>> println "Exit value for module build is: " + >>> moduleBuildResult.getExitValue() >>> if (moduleBuildResult.getExitValue()==0) >>> { >>> getByName('aggregateModuleTests').execute() >>> getByName('distributeProducts').execute() >>> getByName('notifyOfModuleBuildSuccess').execute() >>> } >>> else >>> { >>> println "Error! The module build has NOT been successful. Distributions >>> and consolidated reports will not be made!" >>> getByName('notifyOfModuleErrors').execute() >>> } >>> >>> >>> >>> >>> -- >>> Adam Murdoch >>> Gradle Co-founder >>> http://www.gradle.org >>> VP of Engineering, Gradleware Inc. - Gradle Training, Support, Consulting >>> http://www.gradleware.com >>> >>> >> >
