Manoj,
Perhaps I'm struggling to understand completely, but maybe we should
just go through this one step at a time.
(1) Is the bandwidth issue you're presenty raising between Guacamole and
the local (Xrdp) client - NOT between Guacamole and the remote browser?
On 10/03/2020 4:20 p.m., Manoj Patil wrote:
Dear ivanmarcus,
To be specific. You say MSRDWC uses a lot less bandwidth than
Guacamole, however (if I understand correctly) from what you say
you're using Guacamole with a Xrdp client machine, and MSRDWC with a
MSRD client machine. I suggest you should first test with Guacamole to
the MSRD client, and then MSRDWC to the *same* client with the *same*
parameters and the *same* series of tests. IOW the *only* change in
the lineup is MSRDWC vs Guacamole - NOT the client machine as
I am done the setup of MSRDC at my place and measuring the sam scenario
Guacamole to xrdp client ----
When connecting through browser to guacamole it's low bandwidth . when
connect guacad to xrdp host its huge bandwidth.
Guacamole to MSRDC client--
We test this setup with guacamole to MSRDC host through client there
is also a bandwidth utilization . we measure theough wireshark
MSRDC to same client --
When i am connected to MSRDC with same parameter of bpp, width ,
height etc and measure through wireshark there is tremendous different
, its take very low bandwidth .
When I am in idle mode in guacamole to xrdp its continuously check
keepalive and bandwidth utilizated that time.
When i am in idle in MSRDC there is no keepalive checking see in
wireshark hence bandits is very low .
On Tue, 10 Mar 2020, 02:00 ivanmarcus, <ivanmar...@yahoo.com.invalid>
wrote:
Manoj,
We may have exhausted our ability to help. As Stefan has pointed
out there have been a number of suggestions and explanations
around the issue you raise; it could be useful if you were to
pursue those in the first instance.
One thing that strikes me from your latest post is that you're
introducing too many variables when attempting to compare systems.
If you want to make comparisons then you should start with as
identical a system as possible and change just *one* parameter
first. In this way you will generally be a lot clearer around what
changes have an affect on something.
To be specific. You say MSRDWC uses a lot less bandwidth than
Guacamole, however (if I understand correctly) from what you say
you're using Guacamole with a Xrdp client machine, and MSRDWC with
a MSRD client machine. I suggest you should first test with
Guacamole to the MSRD client, and then MSRDWC to the *same* client
with the *same* parameters and the *same* series of tests. IOW the
*only* change in the lineup is MSRDWC vs Guacamole - NOT the
client machine as well.
Moving on from this, I don't have access to MSRDWC and have never
used it but if possible the next test might be to utilise it with
an Xrdp client machine and compare that with Guacamole to the
*same* client. Such logical steps would lend much more credence to
your results, and may provide a clearer pointer to you as to where
the issue, if there is one, lays.
On 9/03/2020 8:58 p.m., Manoj Patil wrote:
Dear,
Any Resolution on my Issues.
Please suggest any changes at guacamole server and Xrdp host server.
On Tue, 3 Mar 2020 at 13:22, Manoj Patil <manoj2pa...@gmail.com
<mailto:manoj2pa...@gmail.com>> wrote:
Dear
ivanmarcus/mike,
The MSRDP setup is done at my end for testing purpose with
same user ,same screen,same depth etc. we measure the bandith
for singile session and it is too low. i am already sharing a
snapshot in preious mail.
*My point is if i used MSRDP web client to acees the server
it take low bandwidth utilization . when i am using guacd
with xrdp it uses high bandwidth.*
*
*
*
*
