Andreas Hartmann wrote:
Michael Wechner schrieb:
Andreas Hartmann wrote:
Michael Wechner schrieb:
Andreas Hartmann wrote:
Hi Lenya users,
if there is interest in developing 3rd-party modules for Lenya as
open source outside the ASF repository, we could for instance
create a project at Origo (http://www.origo.ethz.ch/). I'd start
with moving the feed and person modules from the sandbox to the
external repository.
why do you want to move the person and feed module outside of the ASF?
IMO the question should be asked the other way round - why should we
keep a particular module in our codebase?
The person module is only used for a tutorial, I think this doesn't
justify keeping it in the repository. Maybe we could add it as a ZIP
file to the documentation.
The feed module is still very rudimentary. It works only with
specific RSS feeds, there's no error handling etc. AFAIK it didn't
gain any interest by others - otherwise a lot of bugs would probably
have been reported :)
As long as I'm the only person who maintains the module, I think it
is inappropriate to keep it in the ASF repository.
so I would ask, why has it actually been added to the sandbox if none
of the other devs was ever interested in these two modules?
Richard mentioned that he might be interested in the feed module
(http://www.nabble.com/News-module---The-module--feed--is-not-registered-td11288451.html#a11288451).
I just noticed his reply, maybe he'll find the time to take a look at
it.
I used the SVN to develop the person module while I was writing the
tutorial and to see if someone might be interested in using it.
I am just saying, that I think one should ask in advance and not use it
for "private" development, but on the other hand stuff within the
sandbox doesn't hurt that much (except taking space).
Cheers
Michael
-- Andreas
So it makes sense to me to move them outside.
Cheers
Michael
WDOT?
Btw, re hosting external modules you might also want to consider
sourceforge or http://www.swissforge.net/
Thanks for the pointers! Swissforge seems to accept only /ch/open
projects, and they seem to have a focus on Swiss projects.
Another option might be codehaus.org, though I don't know if they
would accept to host a kind-of sub-project of an ASF project.
I attended a presentation by one of the Origo founders, they seem to
be very open to all kinds of projects. The technology of the
platform itself is also very interesting. I have to admit that the
future of the platform isn't decided upon, though; they're still
looking for an organization volunteering to provide the
infrastructure on a long-term basis.
-- Andreas
--
Michael Wechner
Wyona - Open Source Content Management - Yanel, Yulup
http://www.wyona.com
[EMAIL PROTECTED], [EMAIL PROTECTED]
+41 44 272 91 61
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
