Hi all! Googling and seraching the archive did not solve my problem, so I will have a try. In my struts-config.xml, I have defined a DynaValidatorForm and an action:
<form-bean name="editForm" type="org.apache.struts.validator.DynaValidatorForm"> <form-property name="projectList" type="java.util.Collection"/> <form-property name="version" type="java.lang.String" initial=""/> </form-bean> <action path="/processEdit" type="com.materna.buc.buildmanager.actions.ProcessEditAction" scope="request" name="editForm" validate="true" input="/WEB-INF/jsp/edit.jsp"> ... </action> As you can see, this form holds a list of projects in a collection, which has to be populated before the corresponding jsp-page is shown. So I have an Action which gets the (dynamic, not static) list of projects from a database and puts it into the editForm like this: public ActionForward execute( ... ) { DynaValidatorForm dynaForm = (DynaValidatorForm) form; // get list of projects from database Collection projectList = getDatabaseHandler().getProjectList(); // put project list into DynaValidatorForm dynaForm.set( "projectList", projectList ); Everything works fine after showing my jsp-page with a combobox populated with the data from my projectList - the user can choose one project. But on the same page there is a html:text field: <html:text name="editForm" property="version" value="1.0" size="7" /> which corresponds to my editForms "version"-property. When the user submits the form to processEdit, the version property has to be validated to see if it is not empty. So in my validation.xml I do the following: <form name="editForm"> <field property="version" depends="required"> <arg0 key="edit.version" /> </field> </form> If the user submits an empty version and validation fails, he will be send back to the jsp-page, but it will not show because the project list is not present any more. That seems clear because the DynaValidatorForm is reset when the user submits. I tried following workarounds: 1. I replaced the DynaValidatorForm with my own version overwriting the reset - method to do nothing. Additionaly set the scope to "session". But my project list gets still lost (wondering why?) 2. Trying to pass my project list from one form to the other like this <html:hidden name="editForm" property="projectList" value="projectList" in all variations always had to fail because the project list will be send as a string and therefore can not be converted back to a collection. I considered to put my project list into application scope, but as it is dynamic, large and not the only (dynamic and large) list to be shown on my jsp-page (I only used it as an example in order not to complicate my question), I am not sure if it is the right way. And writing an ActionForm with own validation and reset methods is a lot of work and would not use the benefits of a DynaValidatorForm... So if you know a trick, solution or workaround, please help! Thanks Peter --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]