Hi Reuti,

> Hi,
> 
> >> What does $hostname stands for? Do you want the job to start on a
> >> particular machine?
> >
> > Precisely.  That is the end goal.
> 
> The syntax in SGE to address a particular host is: -l h=$hostname
> 
> It's not like ssh where you give just the target. But unless there is a
> bold reason, SGE will usually select an appropriate exechost for you.
> That's the purpose of a queuing system.

Actually, my script will use the "-l hostname=$hostname" expansion when someone 
elects to target a specific execution host; but I did not explain that detail.  
My apologies.


> >>> qsub: invalid option argument "-l vl"
> >>
> >> Looks like TCL will give the argument as one, but SGE expects two.
> >> Separating them as "-l" and "vl" might work, on the command line the
> >> splitting is done by the shell where $foo will be split but "$foo"
> >> won't and raise an error too. I have no clue whether TCL has an
> >> option `eval` the expression to split the options.
> >
> > I'm not sure I understand: It does appear as if the "-l" and "vl" are
> separated by a space character.  Is that not enough?
> 
> Not when they are inside a variable: "-l" is the option and "vl" the
> argument to that option. Having "-l vl" is something SGE doesn't understand
> as it should have been broken down. But there is nothing in the TCL
> performing that.
> 
> $ foo="-l h=node29"
> $ qsub "$foo" -b y /bin/sleep 5
> qsub: ERROR! invalid option argument "-l h=node29"
> $ qsub $foo -b y /bin/sleep 5
> Your job 277648 ("sleep") has been submitted
> 
> And it looks like TCL is forwarding the argument like the content of a
> variable is just one option and not option plus argument.

Ah yes, I understand.  And I tried an experiment that processed the args before 
passing them to qsub and that did in fact work.  I'm not sure how I missed 
that; but thanks very much for pointing it out to me!

Best regards,

-- 
Mun


_______________________________________________
users mailing list
[email protected]
https://gridengine.org/mailman/listinfo/users

Reply via email to