Dear QE users, I am currently in the process of learning how to model hydrogen adsorption on a graphene sheet. So, as a starting point I tried to calculate the adsorption energy of hydrogen on boron doped graphene. However, I am unable to obtain values close to those that were stated in papers with similar DFT calculations. Does anyone have any suggestions as to what I might be doing incorrectly? My calculated value was -0.74 eV (please refer to below for input file used) while other papers stated -0.014 eV. I've tried different orientations for the hydrogen molecule (vertical vs horizontal to the graphene sheet) but my final value doesn't change by much (~0.01eV).
&control prefix='h2ads_BG' calculation='relax' outdir = './out' pseudo_dir = '/scratch/Hydrogen_Adsorption/pseudo/' forc_conv_thr=1D-3 / &system ibrav=0, nat=34, ntyp=3, ecutwfc=25, ecutrho=200 occupations='smearing', smearing='methfessel-paxton', degauss=0.01 / &electrons mixing_mode='local-TF' / &ions / CELL_PARAMETERS 18.65816237 0.000000000 0.000000000 9.329081185 16.15844260 0.000000000 0.000000000 0.000000000 28.34588983 ATOMIC_SPECIES C 12.01 C.pbe-van_bm.UPF H 1.001 H.pbe-van_bm.UPF B 10.81 B.pbe-n-van.UPF ATOMIC_POSITIONS angstrom C 1.728024 0.709000 0.001000 C 4.184072 0.709000 0.001000 C 6.640120 0.709000 0.001000 C 9.096169 0.709000 0.001000 C 1.728024 2.127000 0.001000 C 4.184072 2.127000 0.001000 C 6.640120 2.127000 0.001000 C 9.096169 2.127000 0.001000 C 2.931405 2.793323 0.001000 C 5.436735 2.793328 0.001000 C 7.892783 2.793323 0.001000 C 10.324192 2.793323 0.001000 C 2.956048 4.254000 0.001000 C 5.412096 4.254000 0.001000 B 7.868144 4.254000 0.001000 H 7.483935 4.254000 1.220000 H 8.252353 4.254000 1.220000 C 10.324192 4.254000 0.001000 C 4.184072 4.963000 0.001000 C 6.640120 4.963000 0.001000 C 9.096169 4.963000 0.001000 C 11.601494 4.963000 0.001000 C 4.184072 6.381000 0.001000 C 6.640120 6.381000 0.001000 C 9.096169 6.381000 0.001000 C 11.601494 6.381000 0.001000 C 5.412096 7.090000 0.001000 C 7.868144 7.090000 0.001000 C 10.373470 7.090000 0.001000 C 12.829518 7.090000 0.001000 C 5.412096 8.508000 0.001000 C 7.868144 8.508000 0.001000 C 10.373470 8.508000 0.001000 C 12.829518 8.508000 0.001000 K_POINTS automatic 5 5 1 1 1 1 Thank you all in advance. Regards, Janet Wong Graduate Student University of Toronto Canada -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://www.democritos.it/pipermail/pw_forum/attachments/20120410/e2c85228/attachment-0001.htm