> I'm not sure that convertClientId is the proper place for this logic. > > convertClientId seems like its there just to change the clientId to > conform with specific renderer restrictions, independent of the > UIComponent.
The way I see it, the uniqueness of the id's can be considered a specific renderer restriction. Its only XHTML that requires unique ids, not faces. I think that is the key. If faces required it as well, then I would agree, it wouldn't belong in the renderer. > -Heath Borders-Wing sean
