Hello, and thank for pointing out this article on jsp/jsf flaws. However, getting in the docs of facelets, i see to 2 points preventing us to go facelets, maybe your experience can lighten this a bit, if am not abusing your time. 1) facelets use .taglib.xml taglib definition that are not the same as the jsp's .tld file, unfortunately, requiring a new taglib for facelet, the jsp taglib is not wrappable 2) the ui:include tag can only include other facelets, templates or plain XML/XHTML documents. It can not include a .jsp As a matter of fact, it means 1) all our struts based code is not usable in a facelets context as there is no facelets based struts tags 2) because there is no possibility to include a JSP in the result tree, we can't keep our existing jsp part outside facelets and just include them
Am i right in my guess that JSPs can not be easily converted to facelets, except if they were only using the jsp and jstl tags? Mike Kienenberger a écrit : > If you want details on the JSF/JSP issues, see this article: > > http://www.onjava.com/pub/a/onjava/2004/06/09/jsf.html > > > As for converting to facelets, facelets excels at templating. > > > > On 9/11/06, David Delbecq <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: >> Thank you. It's strange, lots of docs i saw on the net about JSF do such >> things as <tag><JSF component/></tag> without problem, it looks very >> curious to me :/ Or maybe i read mistakenly :( >> I'll take a look at facelets, but not sure it will be easy to convert >> all our jsp to facelets as it uses a templating system. :) >> Martin Marinschek a écrit : >> > Hi David, >> > >> > it's inherent to the JSP and JSF 1.1. interaction that this happens - >> > you could call it a bug by design. >> > >> > things you can do, easiest first: >> > >> > - use f:verbatim-tags around your HTML-Code you embed in JSF-tags >> > (simple but ugly) >> > - use the MyFaces htmlTag tag to emit some of the HTML-Tags >> > - use the htmlTag-Library to emit HTML-tags >> > - switch over to Facelets for view-definitions(relatively simple and >> > very recommendable) >> > - switch over to JSF 1.2 (well, if you want to use Tomcat 5.5, you'd >> > still have to use facelets) >> > >> > regards, >> > >> > Martin >> > >> > On 9/11/06, David Delbecq <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: >> >> Hello, >> >> >> >> I thought, in JSP, when i write >> >> <h:form id="blabla"> >> >> <div><h:outputText value="test"/></div> >> >> </h:form> >> >> >> >> I would get something like this >> >> >> >> <FORM> >> >> ... >> >> <div> .... test ... </div> >> >> ... >> >> </FORM> >> >> that is, the content of outputText "test" is placed at same >> position of >> >> corresponding tag. >> >> >> >> However, running such a JSP, is get the following output >> >> >> >> <FORM> >> >> ...test... >> >> <div></div> >> >> ... >> >> </FORM> >> >> >> >> That is, the outputText is rendered immediatly inside the h:form, and >> >> not where is was designed in the JSP, is there a reason for this? >> Am i >> >> forbidden to use html tags inside an h:form?? Is that a bug? >> >> >> > >> > >> >>
