James Knott wrote:
Harold Fuchs wrote:
I see that some experiments have been done to see if it possible to
unsubscribe an address you don't "own" and that in at least some
circumstances the experiments have been successful.
Would someone please explain carefully and clearly
a) What the circumstances are that allow this. In particular, is it
*only* possible when the address being "unsubscribed" (the attacker)
is having its messages forwarded to the person performing the
procedure (the victim)? If not, what other possibilities are there?
You may have more than email account, buy normally only use one SMTP
server. This means you can send any email from address, through that
one SMTP server. I have done this, when sending mail on my personal
account, from my work computer. Unfortunately it also means you can
impersonate someone else. In our example, impersonation would be
necessary, in order to get the subscription ended.
Actually, the impersonation is probably not required for OOo, because
apparently the goodbye message (if received) can be responded to without
regard to the account; it contains a "magic cookie" that is what the
list manager cares about. But it does apparently seem to be necessary
for the attacker to be forwarding the traffic, and not filtering the
goodbye message.
and
b) What exactly is the procedure
Also, if the explanation uses the term "mimic account", would the
explainer please explain what this term means.
Thanks.
I set up my gmail account to forward mail to Barbara and was able to do
so without her password. This means anyone could forward mail to
someone else. In return, Barbara created an account, using my address
as her from address, again without knowing my password. This allowed
her to impersonate me. So, if I had set up forwarding so that she
received list mail, she know can impersonate me to unsubscribe from the
list. However, this does not completely stop someone who is determined
to harass someone in this manner. It might only slow them down a bit.
In my case, setting up a mimic account to impersonate James involved
telling Thunderbird to create a new account, then setting his email
address as the one for the account. Then, when I created the message, I
chose this account in the 'From" dropdown. My outbound SMTP server sent
the message, and James saw it as coming from himself. Note -- I can't
guarantee that this would always work, because I *sometimes* have gotten
a password request when attempting to send mail. It doesn't happen often
enough for me to know what triggers that; the silent acceptance seems
far more frequent. Nor am I entirely sure if it would accept the
password of my account on the SMTP server's domain, or really needs the
password of the "From" account. Since I don't know how to recreate the
situation, I can't really test this.
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]