Why could not the effect you describe be equally achievable by changing the characters? In your example you would initially change the Heading 1 style to be all upper case. Then, when you change your mind, you change it back to title case

No, it's not possible. Format / Change Case has nothing to do with styles.

That means to change all the heading in the document by that method, you would have to find them one by one, and individually highlight them, then select Format / Change Case . . .

I agree that "small caps" is different (see below for my reason), but the others: all upper case, all lower case, sentence case and title case are all switchable by changing characters. It seems very odd to me that all upper and all lower are in one sub-menu while title case is in another and sentence case doesn't exist (except via auto-correct).

The reason they are on separate menus isn't because they are upper case, lower case and title case. They are on separate menus because the do totally different things.

Format / Change Case modifies the characters that are highlighted. In other words, if I accidentally leave my caps lock on, and type a whole paragraph in capital letters, I have made an error that needs to be corrected. I want to change the actual characters to be lower case. So I would use Format / Change Case / Lower Case. The actual characters have now been changed to lowercase. Perhaps the problem is that it is on the Format menu when perhaps the Edit menu is more appropriate.

Format / Character / Font Effects is to help display the text (and especially headings) as capitals. It doesn't actually change the characters from lower case to upper case (or vice versa). It changes the way they appear. This is handy if you want to experiment with making headings caps, lower case, title case or small caps. It is also handy that you can set the Font Effects through styles, so that you can consistently make sure headings are typed in caps or title case whether they were typed that way or not.

So the reason they are on different menus is because they are doing different things, not because they are grouped by (upper, lower) and (capitals, lower case, title, small caps).

<snip>
I can see a technical distinction between changing the character and changing the way it is displayed. This is clearly how fonts work. An A is an A regardless of the font. But I'm not convinced by your example that there is a logical reason for having two different sub-menus and I can see a perfectly logical reason - usability - for having only one. I am also not convinced by your example of the need for using two different techniques, other than for small caps.

Although both features have to do with case, for me, there are two reasons to keep them separate:
1. Function - the reasons you would use these features are quite different
2. They are actually doing two very different things (that admittedly look the same to begin with)

I can't imagine combining them both on one menu. I think you would just leave one of the features out.

Sorry if this is still unclear. Please let me know if it needs further clarification.

Adrian


---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to