I think that we may be seeing some parallels between the effort to amend the FPLA and the way the US Federal Government tried to force metrication in the highway construction business. By taking only what seemed to me to be a "top down" approach, they created a lot more resistance and confusion than was necessary. Instead, they could have organized forums to figure out how to make sure contractors and suppliers would not have to be burdened with maintaining two sets of standards, materials, etc. as well as provide the hands-on training and coaching to ease their concerns about and lack of familiarity with the metric system.
 
I worry that simply pushing to amend the FPLA may generate needless opposition (as we see already from the FMI) because folks have not analyzed the collateral issues that arise for businesses that will have to cope with perhaps more complexity rather than less in the wake of some manufacturers moving to metric-only packaging. Some concerns may be ill-founded that can be dispelled with proper education; others may prove to be valid concerns that can be suitably addressed with a little forethought, understanding, and coordination among all parties concerned.
 
At the end of the day I think taking an integrated view of how to create the appropriate solution will turn out to be the most effective and successful approach.
 
Ezra
 
----- Original Message -----
Sent: Sunday, August 28, 2005 5:45 PM
Subject: [USMA:34162] Re: My head says yes, my heart says no...

With containerized food (box, tub, bottle, jar) few people really pay attention to the measurement of the container.  They buy the small, big, or Costco-sized box of Cheerios, jar of mayonnaise, bottle of soda, etc.   You could take the lb and oz (all kinds) off the container and few would notice.

 

The only time they get worried about pounds is at the deli counter.  In reality, too, the deli counter has varying sizes of containers, and people want the little one, the medium one, the big one, because I’ll bet that few of them know exactly what quantity (visual amount) of food they’re going to get when they ask for a “pound”.  (It’ll be a lot more for hollow noodles than for potato salad, for one thing.)  However, they feel dumb asking for it by container so they ask by “pound” and guess at what they’re going to get.

 

The last resistance will be at the deli and produce counters – perhaps we could call this the “Steven Thoburn” effect!

 

Carleton

 


From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Daniel
Sent: Sunday, August 28, 2005 20:28
To: U.S. Metric Association
Subject: [USMA:34160] Re: My head says yes, my heart says no...

 

You'd be surprised to find you are not alone.  Most people aren't there either.  They all fake it to one degree or another.  That is why the majority just know the extreme basics.

 

Which reminds me.  I was in a Chinese Restaurant last night and a woman came in wanting to order carry-out.  The hostess/cashier must have been telling her what sizes the dinners come in because the woman loudly said: "What's a quart?".  The cashier held up a container to show her. 

 

Not everyone is afraid to ask if don't know what it is assumed they know.

 

Dan

 

 

----- Original Message -----

Sent: Sunday, 2005-08-28 20:15

Subject: [USMA:34158] Re: My head says yes, my heart says no...

 

Jim,

 

And I didn't mean to be critical in my post.  It's just I don't have the problem, I never really learned ifp well and as a result don't have an attachment.

 

All my life ifp has simply been a PITA I put up with.  Volume units such as "quart" or "fluid ounce" were something I learned by rote in grade school, but quickly forgot because there was no underlying logic. As a result I judged liquid volume by appearance, until the late 70's when I was doing a dissertation on liquid helium (always measured in liters) and 2-liter Coke first appeared. As a result the liter was the first unit of liquid measure I ever really learned.

 

Similar with other aspects.  I could never see why a mile had to be 5280 of anything, or why water had to freeze at 32. So I guess I'm not nostalgic because I was just never "there" in the first place.

 

Nat   

 


From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of James J. Wentworth
Sent: Sunday, 28 August 2005 19:35
To: U.S. Metric Association
Subject: [USMA:34156] Re: My head says yes, my heart says no...

Hello All,

 

I'm not suggesting for a moment that the UK should not complete its metrication as quickly as possible--I was simply expressing a strange feeling of ambivalence that I never thought I'd have.  A goal you've been striving for is within reach, and suddenly you have doubts about your very desire to reach it.  It's strange.

 

I know this is entering the realm of the "touchy-feely," but perhaps gaining an understanding of these emotions can be helpful in formulating the US metrication plans.  The SI is rational, but humans are not, at least not all of the time.  Any successful venture to change humans' ways without force of arms has to take this into account.  --  Jason 


No virus found in this incoming message.
Checked by AVG Anti-Virus.
Version: 7.0.344 / Virus Database: 267.10.16/83 - Release Date: 2005-08-26

Reply via email to