Remek, Quite right: agreement. But, Australians agreed without coercion. The word "voluntary" takes on a new meaning when most people and institutions assent to the change and then carry it out. I agree with you that metrication doesn't work when "voluntary" means "only if you want to." ----- Original Message ----- From: Remek Kocz To: U.S. Metric Association Cc: U.S. Metric Association Sent: 23 October, 2008 18:39 Subject: [USMA:41884] Compact Fluorescents: a botched conversion in progress.
The marketing of compact fluorescent lightbulbs is a poignant lesson in what happens when "voluntary" is the name of the game when a conversion to a new standard is concerned. CF's will replace incandescent bulbs in 5-10 years, no question about that. The industry is rushing out new products at breakneck pace. Yet, there are no labeling or conversion rules--it's a free for all. And it's quite obvious when one takes a look at a display of the bulbs. Some manufacturers use new wattage numbers. Most shy away, and in big print show the old wattages, while hiding the smaller numbers. Some don't even bother with the new wattages. Yet, internally, Lowe's and Home Depot use the new numbers. A simple solution would be to force all manufacturers to display only the new wattages on the lightbulbs. No more 60-75-100 watts but 15-18-23. The retailer would be provided with a conversion chart that could be posted at the lightbulb display, and in a matter of a year or so, the consumers would learn the new numbers. This is precisely why I don't believe that the words "choice" or "voluntary" belong in the process of metric conversion. There needs to be a centralized push for metrication, and I guarantee it won't come from the corporate world. We can live lives of "hidden metric" and "mass-consumption imperial" indefinitely. Nothing, absolutely nothing motivates a profit oriented entity to educate the consumer to use new units (see above) as long as market share is maintained or expanded. Yet it could be so easy: Coca-Cola decides to go all the way, and tells their bottlers to phase in new sizes. All of the sudden, Coke soft drinks can be had in 500, 600, and 700 mL sizes. Their Minute Maid juices show up in 2 L, 1.75 L, and 1L bottles. Pepsi (and their Tropicana brand) follows suit. Once the big boys switch, everyone else just follows. When I met our very own Pat Naughtin in Toronto, I asked a question how it was done in Australia, how were all these disparate interests convinced to go metric? The gist of his answer was that at the time, everyone agreed that metrication was what was needed to be done. In America, we need to get to this tipping point. I hope that someday we will.
