> Your utrace-ptrace-compat kernel is not the full utrace implementation which
> the testsuite targets, it is only its `regset' part.  Therefore some (all?)
> of the crashers just do not apply to such non-full-utrace kernels.

That is not true, unless I am misunderstanding what you are referring to.
utrace-ptrace-compat is the "everything of utrace" branch.  

(The kernels you tested a while back that were "just regset parts" were not
any of the existing utrace branches at all, but based on the user_regset
patch series that is now in 2.6.25-rc1.)

> Even if it would be the full utrace kernel all the crasher problems were
> already fixed except clone-get-signal which has unfortunately very rare
> reproducibility.  It reproduces probably best on s390.  Still it was seen even
> on x86_64.  It is unfortunately very probably your machine just did not
> reproduce it.

Since these were intermittent race crashes, I don't like to declare that we
are sure they are fixed just because previously reliable reproducers no
longer crash for us.  I hope that's so, but that's why more long and
grueling testing is good to have.


Thanks,
Roland

Reply via email to