On Wed, 2004-03-10 at 11:19, Tony Despain wrote:
> Andrew,
> 
>      I am not sure if I want to use roaming profiles either, but if you 
> could give me some of those many reasons as to why a samba pdc wouldn't work 
> well I would like to hear them.

There's no reason why a Samba PDC won't do roaming profiles right
(recent versions anyway), it's roaming profiles themselves that are
wrong.

The big reason is that roaming profiles only really work if all of the
client workstations are the same configuration exactly, same OS version,
same applications, etc. Hardware configuration doesn't matter, but most
applications have to be in the very same paths to work properly.

Another problem we ran into was data getting into the profile that
shouldn't. Mozilla/Netscape was a classic example, the cache is stored
in the "Application Data" folder instead of the "Local Settings" folder,
which means that their whole cache goes with them wherever they roam. An
extreme example was the MSDN documentation. The docs are absolutely
huge. The index it created was also huge (like 680MB)... and stored in
the "Application Data" folder also, so again this gets dragged around
with the profile. Eventually it starts to take around 30min to log on
(or off, I don't recall which).

The fundamental problem is that application developers (including MS)
don't plan for roaming profile support so things get broken.

>      We have many users that need some type of roaming profiles and policies 
> set so they can't download tons of crap onto the computer.  We are even 
> thinking of making all the workstations into linux workstations if there is 
> a way to do roaming profiles with that.  Let me know what you think.

Policies can be set in better ways than defaults in the profile,
unfortunately the best way (by far) is to run a real windows domain and
set up group policies for the users. Some of that can be done without a
windows domain too, but it's very involved.

Honestly, Linux is a pretty good idea. I'm not a fan of NFS, but it will
do the job right. Again you'd need to have basically the same setup on
all machines though.


____________________
BYU Unix Users Group 
http://uug.byu.edu/ 
___________________________________________________________________
List Info: http://uug.byu.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/uug-list

Reply via email to