On Wed, 2004-03-17 at 19:22, Kirk Coombs wrote:
> I chose SuSE over Mandrake for several reasons:
> 
> 1. I thought that YaST was much better than the configuration tools in
>  Mandrake.  The deciding factor was actually their package manager,
>  which I felt beat Mandrake hands down.  I also like that YaST works
>  just as well from the command-line as it does in X.  I didn't have any
>  trouble with updates in SuSE; it must have been a mirror problem you
>  had.  I have acutally encountered that before.

The configuration tools in Mandrake have improved dramatically in the
past couple years (I don't know when you saw them last).  You should
take another look at them, though since you are used to YaST (what's
with this, capitalize-every-letter-but-the-second thing SuSE has going
on anyway?) it may still seem better.  I know I was a little biased
toward Mandrake's control center because of familiarity.

> 2. It came with a TON of packages (5 CD's).  Mandrake seemed to be a
>  little lacking in that area (3 CD's). 

Since I download it all off of the web (ISOs or individual rpms) I don't
care too much about what comes on CD, just as long as I can find an rpm
somewhere.  Like Jake said, if you pay you can get a bunch of CDs from
Mandrake.

>  At the time Mandrake didn't
>  have URPMI (that's the APT equivalent, right?) so I had trouble
>  getting the packages I wanted.  Now Mandrake have URPMI, and SuSE
>  doesn't have an equivalent.  So... That argument may be invalid now.
>  (That's one of the reasons I am thinking of trying Mandrake)

Dude, if you don't have a tool that resolves package dependencies for
you these days, you are using ancient technology indeed.  In my google
searching I seem to remember I found yum ported to SuSE as well as some
other SuSE specific tool that was being written.  You might look into
those.  Or just try Mandrake.

> 3. I didn't have any trouble getting the free version of SuSE.  At
>  Novell, I can get those ISO's before it is even oficially released.

Lucky you :P
 
>  If you would like some help in this area, I may be able to assist.

Can you really do that?  

> 
> 4. I liked SuSE's artwork much better.

Agreed.  Mandrake 9.2 looks pretty nice though (I'll start the upgrade
to 10 after this email).  There is something cool about lizards, I think
that's why SuSE wins.

> 6. SuSE's hardware support was better.  I could not get Mandrake to
> detect my USB hardware for the life of me.

I don't know about your specific hardware, but I had my mother-in-law's
Nikon camera and my dad's sony camera, and they both just worked in
Mandrake.  Plugged them in, turned them on and a little hard drive icon
appeared on the desktop.  They worked just fine.  Just for fun I tried
them both on my windoze 2000 box, and they didn't work at all.  It
complained about drivers missing.  My HP camera works great with
Mandrake too.  With a little work I even got my friends Nomad Jukebox to
work, that's what I had to compile the other day :(

> 7. I generally felt that SuSE was much better evolved than Mandrake.

To me SuSE felt a little more polished too.  Almost stiff.  Business
like.  Mandrake has been accused of instability before, and I think that
used to be true, but it's really good now (crossing my fingers for 10). 
A lot more home user friendly feel than SuSE, I think.  This is just an
impression I have.

> Feedback on these comparisons would be appreciated.

Hope that helps,

Bryan


____________________
BYU Unix Users Group 
http://uug.byu.edu/ 
___________________________________________________________________
List Info: http://uug.byu.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/uug-list

Reply via email to