On Thu, Mar 18, 2004 at 10:21:52PM -0700, Soren Harward wrote:
> At the end of our meeting this evening, Evan asked a very good question
> which I didn't immediately understand, and therefore I didn't really give
> him a good answer.  I think I understand the question a little better now,
> so hopefully I can give a better answer.
> 
> Evan's question was basically, "how is it possible to simulate a real-world
> system on a computer with any sort of accuracy?"  The basic answer is that
> "if you can quantify the system (represent it through numbers and
> functions), you can simulate it on a computer."

Yes, truly.  I want to say more on this later.

> ...
>
> So the basis of scientific computing is to represent everything with
> numbers and functions.  Max Cohen, the protagonist of "Pi" (a movie I highly
> recommend seeing if you take the MPAA with a grain of salt), stated it as
> such: "Restate my assumptions: 1. Mathematics is the language of nature. 2.
> Everything around us can be represented and understood through numbers. 3.
> If you graph these numbers, patterns emerge. Therefore: There are patterns.
> Everywhere around us."
> 
> ...
> 
> So as much as us in the physical sciences look down on the computer
> scientists, most of our problems wouldn't be solvable without the work that
> the CS majors have already put in to solving problems that they didn't think
> would ever have an application.  Since they've already done the
> computational grunt work, the physical scientists can worry about the
> higher-level refinement of their models.

Perhaps nobody here really cares, but coming to an absolute understanding of nature is 
quite the epic philosophical quandary amongst the more abstract, or as I like to think 
of it, fundamental, sciences.  Whether or not the TOE is actually attainable or 
forever beyond reach as the asymptotic limit of exact human knowledge.  But physics is 
just some collection of provable assumptions written and worked out in the language of 
mathematics.  It has nothing to do with reality except that it seems to be able to 
simulate it with a certain degree of precision, but can never touch it.

Suppose the gravitational field of the Earth were tomorrow to turn off [conjecture for 
example's sake] or the Universe was discovered to be accelerating in its expansion 
[actually happened].  Physics most likely could tell you nothing about such radical, 
unexpected phenomena, for physics can only observe, predict, and measure.  None of 
these three maxims are powerful enough to imbue physics of veracity regarding any 
physical verity.  Or rather, by physical means, nothing can ever be known.

This is the utter paramount of scientific understanding: a direct theory based on raw 
material facts and unbiased mechanical reason verified by all possible relevant 
experimentation.  Anyone who credits science for more or less than this is selling 
something and shouldn't be believed, for we all know who the only imparter of truth is.

More practically stated, a complete understanding derives from the sufficiency 
condition of whether or not all random error is eventually identifiable as systemmatic 
error.  This implies both a comprehensive understanding of the rules of nature and 
enough computational power to easily implement them in any arbitraty complexity of 
configurations.

Chemistry and biology aside, there are enough raw physics problems and to spare for 
the world's supercomputers to crunch on for a very, very long time.


Justin

____________________
BYU Unix Users Group 
http://uug.byu.edu/ 
___________________________________________________________________
List Info: http://uug.byu.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/uug-list

Reply via email to