In this case, it's simply a desire to control the look of the window, precisely. Specifically, the layout takes up a known amount of space -- making the window larger is not really a problem -- you'd just have the content+blank space. But making the window smaller is pretty much a disaster from a design perspective, because the content does not reflow gracefully (or even predictably).
We're utilizing scrollable areas within the window itself, but we want the main window to be fixed.
Dave
Aside from the UI design concerns I already expressed for making it play well on multiple platforms, I occasionally help people get cheap laptops for school/home/whatever. Typically these are older laptops with 800x600 LCD screens, and we have regular difficulties with apps whose windows don't fit entirely on-screen (web based ones in particular being the most egregious offenders). Another group I deal with (and is mostly outside the scope of the SSS cd, but I am going to plead with you anyway) are apps that otherwise run properly, but do not display correctly on sub-notebooks, handhelds, and PDAs.
The flip side (making windows larger) is more a personal issue. It is irritating to resize a window to 1400x1200 and still have to scroll through a list of 8 items because the pane within the window refuses to resize larger than 200x100.
Scrollbars on the window itself should appear when the window is resized too small. If too large, then generally users don't care whether there is empty space between the objects like buttons etc. Panes within the window should follow the same rule, scrollbars only appearing when resized too small, but allowing the entire pane to be visible if resized up. This allows a usable (if not perfectly pretty) display on a large majority of devices.
Anyway, don't take my gripes here too seriously, UI design (and non-resizable windows in particular) has simply become a pet peeve of mine.
I know you have put a good amount of work into the SSS cd, and I know it does a great deal of good in the community. I very much appreciate that.
Thanks for listening,
Adam Augustine____________________
BYU Unix Users Group http://uug.byu.edu/ ___________________________________________________________________
List Info: http://uug.byu.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/uug-list
