On Wed, 2004-10-06 at 21:24, Scott Paul Robertson wrote:
> Theres been a lot of good comments about this so far, and since I'm
> actually at my computer now, I think I'll have my try.
> 
> Knoppix is the only install that I'm aware of not being long, hard, and
> intimidating. But thats only in one area. FC2 is still a blindingly fast
> install when you have a decent cd drive and decent speed HD. You joked
> about Gentoo, and I'd point out, as many people know, that's a long,
> hard, intimidating install.

As we all know, particularly with Fedora, installation is only a small
part of the problem.  (Unless you use gentoo--then it's most of the
problem :).

> I'm not speaking from experience, but would it be too much of a guess
> that OSX is almost one giant binary or disk image with a little tweaking
> once it's installed? Apple has the platform advantage in that they
> control the hardware, they don't have to cover their bases with
> ump-teen-billion drivers/kernel modules. Knoppix is quick because it is
> a copy of a currently running ram-disk image.

Knoppix probably installs to disk faster than OS X.  OS X's ease of use
and installation has little to do with the hardware, though.  OS X
really is a masterful front-end on a BSD distribution.  There is some
internal concept of packages, although I have no idea how they are
managed (this is sad, as a Powerbook is one of my primary systems).  I
know that once you're past initial install, with the exception of
drivers and subsystems, installing applications is completely done
without any package management system.  Just drop a app folder in
/Applications.  That's all there is to it.  I was extremely impressed
when I discovered the Gimp.app package for OS X that wraps up all the
dependencies in a nice little self-contained package that actually
integrates with the OS, despite the fact that it's still a non-mac,
straight-unix app requiring X11.  Not a perfect system, since 99% of mac
apps do not use shared libraries between them.  But with large hard
drives, who cares.  For things like .Net, Java, or other widely used
libraries (perl, python, etc), there is a /Libraries/Framework area that
packages can install too.

> 
> Overall I wish that there was a distro that installed as smoothly as
> OSX, but there isn't, and we're at a disadvantage when you consider what
> variety exists in hardware. One day it might go faster, but I'm not too
> sure.

I was running OS X on my Pentium 4 3.2 gHz workstation today.  PearPC is
making amazing progress as an emulator.

> 
> Personally I feel that the part of the installfest that really is
> intimidating is watch me compile kernel modules for wireless cards, and
> still not having it work. Till Linux has a broader wireless support I
> don't expect any Linux distro to be a great experience. There are a few
> lucky people who bring laptops that are supported, but those seem to be
> less and less. Vendor support doesn't exist for some (any ndiswrapper
> card) and is only recently begun (Centrino). With the fact that so many
> laptop makers are using these new-fangled-not-linux-friendly cards, what
> can we expect?

I learn a lot about how weak linux is in many areas going to install
fest.  Maybe there are things we can do to mitigate some of these
problems, like having the patched kernels ready to go (8k-stacks for
ndiswrapper) and the driver already compiled for that specific kernel.

The future in this area is bright or dim, depending on how you look at
it.  Vendor support will not improve significantly while MS is
dominant.  On the other hand, new kernel-level features from the
freedesktop project such as HAL and D-BUS enable things to work a lot
more smoothly and automatically in the future.  It's conceivable that in
the near future, a program will be written that listens on the D-BUS for
hardware and compile the driver on the fly for it (using ndiswrapper if
need be).  That would be real progress.  But we're a long way from that
now.  

Work is being done also to make it easier to set up devices without
requiring root knowledge.  USB key drives, scanners, cameras, etc.

I've come to the conclusion that for now, Linux is a great OS for
everyday use if and only if a) you are a hobbiest who loves playing
around and getting your hands dirty or b) someone maintains it for you. 
And I'm uncomfortable recommending it right now to a non-techie if I
know I can't spend significant time to support them.

In the meantime I can't support my friends and families machines
(windows or linux) so I'm recommending Macs.  So far they've supported
themselves very well.
> 
> The distros are going to get better in installation, but until some
> vendors pull their heads from their <censored for your benifit>,
> post-install issues will still exist.

Which vendors?  RedHat?  Surely you know the intellectual property
restrictions they work under.  Talking about mp3, dvd, etc.  

The rest of the stuff, yes you are right.  But no one vendor owns linux,
so improvements can come from many places.

> 
> Now to part two of my rant:
> 
> What distro. FC2 is in the CS Dept labs. Traditionally we've gotten a
> good number of people from CS 240 and a few other classes. I know cadaem
> uses Debian in their labs (but alas, all my classes us Windows), but
> we've never had too much of a demand. Mandrake is a good alternitive,
> and is quite a easy newbies distro (IMHO). We've actually installed it
> on a good number of machines at the past 2 installfests.
> 
> If someone wants to install something else on a friends machine, thats
> fine. If someone else wants to push something on everyone they help,
> thats fine (as long as they support). FC2 seems to have the advantage
> that most of us know it to some degree. I work with FC2 and RHEL, and
> run FC1 on my server. I feel pretty comfortable on it.
> 
> FC2 (and mandrake) both seem to encourage the "new-user" helpfullness,
> while I've never gathered that from Debian, but I could be wrong.
> 
> If theres a distro that should be considered as one of our club made on
> hand distro, bring us an example system, something to see how it works.

We could always make our own!  :)  Just kidding.

> 
> These are my personal opinions, and if you've survived this rant,
> congratulations, I'm going to my homework now.

I'm still breathing, although my vision has blurred somewhat.
-- 
Michael Torrie <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>

____________________
BYU Unix Users Group 
http://uug.byu.edu/ 
___________________________________________________________________
List Info: http://uug.byu.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/uug-list

Reply via email to