On Thu, 2004-10-07 at 13:34 -0600, Justin Findlay wrote:

> 
> But just handing out OSX to newbies?  I thought the idea was to share the
> free software goodness.  ``Respect copyright, save money, and gain absolute
> control over your computer: use free software.''

Well, no one said anything about not promoting free software goodness.
And free software doesn't mean they have to use linux either.  I think
that free software goodness can and will touch everyone, but not
necessarily solely through linux.  Using the gimp, openoffice, firefox,
and other core apps is a real win for open source and free software in
general.

> 
> As complex as computers really are (how many dozen million lines of source
> code for an installed distro? not to mention hardware ecclecticsm) can we
> honestly expect a simple install on every box, even for an experienced user?
> Consider also that macs have succeeded in not just cutting the software
> heterogenity of paradigms, establishing a religion of an implementation, but
> also the hardware complexity.
> 
> Yes, welcome to the real world.  Simplistic expectations of technical human
> made stuff cannot really suffice, and rarely do.  Newbie can't be made to
> expect their distro to function as easily and flexibly as windows (does
> windows really?), software is brittle.   The newbie must be educated along
> with their install that no computer will work as expected or as advertized
> all the time if windows was responsible for introducing them to computers
> without educating them about the complexity thereof.

Yup.  I'm now for more concerned with minimizing the time and effort I
need to put in to make computers work for my friends and family.  The
truth is that Windows over time does get very expensive for me to
maintain for my friends and neighbors.  If I had good fast connections
to all their machines, then I could cheaply maintain a bunch of linux
boxes, since I could employ standard unix admin skills to remotely
maintain them all at the same time.  Unfortunately this is not
available, so the only real choice is a computer system that is largely
self sufficient.  OS X has proven to be pretty good at that.

> 
> If such a newbie exerts simplistic expectations over their newly installed
> distro, they will likely be disapointed, for it is not hard to break a
> distro and it can be very hard to fix one when you have no initial knowledge
> of the nature of the fracture, or how to mend it.

Well we are competing against the Microsoft marketing machine. MS would
have our prospective newbies believe that linux is more complicated,
harder to set up, and less capable than Windows.  And when newbies hit
these snags, unless they really want to hate MS, will come to believe
these things.  

> 
> 
> Justin
> 
> ____________________
> BYU Unix Users Group 
> http://uug.byu.edu/ 
> ___________________________________________________________________
> List Info: http://uug.byu.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/uug-list
-- 


____________________
BYU Unix Users Group 
http://uug.byu.edu/ 
___________________________________________________________________
List Info: http://uug.byu.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/uug-list

Reply via email to