On Thu, Oct 20, 2005 at 12:23:15AM -0600, Michael Moore wrote: > There are three main factors I think we should consider: > > 1) Focus changed from making a Software for Starving Students CD to > making the infrastructure (scripts, database and config files) for > creating any type of "Software For" CD. SSS would continue to be made, > but not as much of an emphasis.
Not an Issue. If it's an infrastructure it makes it easier to tweak to our needs. > 2) The other big change that happened recently was that the focus > moved from Open Source to handy Freeware. Utilites like Spybot S&D, > and AVG antivirus are to be included. > See here: http://uvlug.org/wiki/doku.php?id=docs:programs:sss:windows > and the "Purpose and Focus" threads here: > http://uvlug.org/pipermail/sss/2005-August/ > > While OSS is still prefered, it is not the main emphasis. You can read > the notes from an organizational meeting here: > http://uvlug.org/pipermail/sss/2005-September/000114.html [Warning: Rant Begins] Looking at the uug website, I notice that we describe ourselves thusly: "The UUG is a club whose members are Linux/Unix enthusiasts. We advocate the use of open source software and open standards in computing. "The UUG aims to encourage, train and support people using the UNIX and Linux operating systems." Advocating doesn't mean shunning non-OSS software. As I see it the SSS CD was designed to bring attention to our club, and offer a service to students. That service, as I see it, is providing students with easy access to free and useful programs that they might not otherwise have access to. I think an overtly focusing on the license is ignoring our chance to be helpful to the BYU community. People do need anti-virus and spyware-removal programs. The SSS CD is about providing a service, and I think it would be sad if we loss the ability to provide this service because the CD is no longer an exclusive BYU-UUG production or because it includes a few useful programs that aren't OSS. <snip> > My Argument: It's my view that the UUG's focus should be *nix > operating systems, Free/Open Source software, and helping other > appreciate them. I think that including non-OSS software shifts the > purpose of the CD from FOSS towards a usefull-Windows-stuff type CD. > While this type of CD is undoubtedly usefull, and worth passing on to > friends, I don't think it does as good of a job at promoting Open > Source. Some of the non-"free" items on the current proposed list seem dumb to include, in my opinion. It does seem to push towards "useful windows CD", which is missing the point a bit. But that doesn't mean we should shun the CD, or the developers because of it. While it may be a few versions away, if Dave is going for the infrastructure option I think the real solution is this: modify the product offering on the CD to fit more what we want. I think the ubuntu live CD option is not a good long term solution: Not everyone in the group likes ubuntu, and future members may have no interest in supporting the development of a ubuntu based CD to distribute (I for one don't). Some people may think it's cool to do a mixed SSS style CD with a live Linux distro, but I think the general population of BYU doesn't care about trying out Linux, they care about being able to do things like photoshop without pirating the software, and that is the power of the SSS CD. I don't want to see the club turn its back on a project that it started, and has continued to be developed by alumni of the group. -- Scott Paul Robertson http://spr.mahonri5.net GnuPG FingerPrint: 09ab 64b5 edc0 903e 93ce edb9 3bcc f8fb dc5d 7601
signature.asc
Description: Digital signature
-------------------- BYU Unix Users Group http://uug.byu.edu/ The opinions expressed in this message are the responsibility of their author. They are not endorsed by BYU, the BYU CS Department or BYU-UUG. ___________________________________________________________________ List Info: http://uug.byu.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/uug-list
