Hello Michael,

On Thu, 13 Aug 2009 11:38:38 +0200, Michael Thayer wrote
> If you indeed de-installed the VirtualBox networking component, then 
> the networking parts of VirtualBox are running with the same rights 
> as any other process the user might start (Mikhail, please correct 
> me here if I am saying anything wrong for Windows hosts). 

Doesn't it have some code running in kernel mode? 

> Your 
> users have root rights inside the virtual machine, but on the host 
> they do not get any special rights as far as networking is concerned 
> (in fact generally, VirtualBox is designed to run with as few extra 
> privileges as possible). This can be compared to the way root rights 
> on one machine in a network doesn't give you special privileges on 
> other machines.

Agree. However, having root rights on the guest os users can run some sort of 
program that they could not run inside the host os as ordinary users. For 
example, they can run programs like nmap from the guest os and not from host 
os simply because they cannot install it in the host os. They could install on 
guest os any other prohibited program that they could not install on host 
system (due to the lack of rights and the security policy).

> In particular, unless you set up port forwarding, any server which they
> set up on a virtual machine will not even be accessible from the host

You are right. In fact, since WinXP just allow us to block inbound 
connections, it is blocked. On the other hand, WinXP does not allow us to 
block outbound connections.

>In particular, all host firewall rules still apply.
Yes, the only concern now is with the outbound connections. WinXP's Firewall 
is not able to block it (just inbound).

Regards

-- 
Esta mensagem foi verificada pelo sistema de antivĂ­rus e
 acredita-se estar livre de perigo.


_______________________________________________
vbox-users mailing list
[email protected]
http://vbox.innotek.de/mailman/listinfo/vbox-users

Reply via email to