Re: [VFB] Perpetual proposal, part 1 reply

[DMurphy832]

In a message dated 11/20/2004 11:27:52 PM, [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: I like your ideas, but I would also think that a swapmeister could go the extra mile and give constructive criticism based on a fly submitted or even a photo emailed of the intended pattern for the swap.  On all of the swaps I have meistered I have emailed the participants with constructive criticism or advice on how to tie the submitted fly better.  Don, You have a good handle on the purpose of swapping.  I enter swaps to hone my own skills, pick up pattern/technique info, get feedback from others and get to know folks better.  I'm 100% behind your comments regarding swappers putting their 100% into the flys they submit whether they are beginners or experts.  Sometimes others will critique my entry or offer advice but not as often as I'd like.  Probably some are afraid of hurting feelings or not quite comfortable with their perception of their own abilities.  While sensitive, I gain a lot from input from others.  Some tyers have great sense of proportions, others have mastered application of materials while a select few have mastered all the critical aspects.  Everyone has something to share which is why I try to read as many listers' posts as possible.   Murf David T. Murphy 14126 Harrisville Road Mount Airy, Maryland 21771-7914 Home & Office: 301-607-9047 Cellular: 301-370-6067